Screenplays admired by Tarantino: dialogue, structure and the finished film

Tarantino has discussed other people’s writing in specific contexts. His comments offer a way to examine dialogue and narrative construction without creating a definitive ranking of the best screenplays in history.

A conversation about writing offers identifiable examples

In November 2003, a conversation between Tarantino and Brian Helgeland, moderated by Lynn Hirschberg for The New York Times, included an exchange about favourite screenplays. Tarantino mentioned, among others, His Girl Friday, Rio Bravo and Hero. This is a specific source about writing, distinct from a poll that simply asks about favourite films.

His Girl Friday shows how dialogue can drive action. The lines try to persuade, hold on, deceive or regain an advantage. The verbal pace matters because each character has a relationship with what the other wants. If the words were merely clever, the conversation could bring the story to a halt; here, they help move it forward.

The screenplay also needs to organize information that different people know to varying degrees. The audience may understand a ploy before one of its targets does, then wait to see its effect. That difference fuels humour and tension. The writing distributes who knows what, when they reveal it and what they are trying to achieve by saying it.

Recognizing this construction does not mean attributing everything in the finished film to the screenwriter. Acting, directing and editing realize the text’s possibilities through specific choices. Praise for the dialogue can go hand in hand with admiration for the way it is delivered. Separating the roles helps us understand how they work together without turning them into compartments that never affect one another.

Rio Bravo and Hero: spending time with characters and distinguishing results

Rio Bravo connects a threatening situation with the time a group spends together. The story lets us learn about their abilities, wounds and ways of treating one another without entirely abandoning the conflict. Writing can sustain interest through shared time as well as by setting up events. The audience returns to a conversation because it already recognizes what it means to the people taking part.

Progress does not require every scene to introduce a spectacular twist. An exchange can change the level of trust or reveal a limit that will matter later. This accumulation gives the characters a sense of history. When a decision comes, the viewer can draw on earlier experiences to understand why someone might make it that way.

Hero, known in Spain as Héroe por accidente, illustrates a distinction Tarantino made in that exchange: he thought more highly of the screenplay than of the resulting film. The example shows that admiring the writing and admiring the filmmaking do not always go hand in hand. An idea, a structure or a group of characters can be compelling even if the film’s execution does not satisfy the reader of the text.

Comparing page and screen requires an identified version. Published screenplays may reflect different stages of the process and do not always include every change made during filming. A discrepancy does not, by itself, prove that someone ruined the work. It allows us to ask what was kept, what was changed and what effect that decision had on the whole.

Aaron Sorkin and the need for caution when discussing Paul Schrader

In May 2020, Première recalled Tarantino’s admiration for Aaron Sorkin as a dialogue writer, along with his choice of The Social Network as the film of the decade. These are related assessments, but they are not the same as a universal list of screenplays ranked by quality. Nor do they allow us to claim that every work by Sorkin received the same praise.

The Social Network offers a style of writing in which speaking quickly does not eliminate the need to listen. Responses can correct an interpretation, deflect an accusation or reveal an ambition. The exchanges gain energy because people do not always want to answer the question they are asked. Verbal tension arises from conflicting goals, as well as from the skill involved in crafting memorable lines.

Tarantino’s opinion of Paul Schrader requires a different nuance. His interest in films such as Taxi Driver and Rolling Thunder should not be reduced to unconditional approval of every version of their screenplays. In Cinema Speculation, he discusses films, decisions and alternative possibilities. Critical commentary can include both admiration and disagreement along the way.

Film writing also encompasses actions without dialogue. An entrance, a pause or a piece of visual information can reshape a scene. Reducing the best screenplays to their most quotable lines would leave out the structure that gives those lines meaning. The relationship between scenes, shifts in knowledge and the setup of consequences are all part of the same work. Even a memorable line needs the right listener and the right moment to be more than an isolated quip.

Documented examples help us recognize fruitful questions: how a conversation becomes a conflict, how a group sustains interest and how a film transforms a text. They do not amount to a definitive ranking of the entire history of screenwriting. Tarantino appears as a reader and viewer who distinguishes different aspects of works, and that distinction offers more tools for analysing them than a collection of compliments presented as if they all meant exactly the same thing.

Go back to films recommended by Tarantino.

View all articles in Films Recommended by Tarantino: Sources and Selections