Tarantino, Netflix and the case for theatrical releases

The discussion is about how a film reaches audiences and becomes a shared event, not just about the size of the screen.

The criticism at Cannes in 2023

In his interview with Baz Bamigboye for Deadline during Cannes 2023, Tarantino defended theatrical releases and questioned the cultural impact of productions made directly for platforms. He used Ryan Reynolds’ films for Netflix as an example, saying he had not watched them. The comment expressed his distance from that model of distribution; it was not a review based on watching each title.

This distinction avoids a common mistake: presenting an admitted lack of familiarity with a film as a detailed assessment of its quality. It is also worth separating a controversial remark from a literal description of the audience. The fact that a work has not been part of Tarantino’s experience does not mean that nobody has watched, remembered or discussed it. The statement expresses a cultural preference; it does not, by itself, provide an audience measurement.

His position is easier to understand if we distinguish between two moments: a film’s release and its subsequent life. Arguing that its first screening should be in a cinema does not mean denying that it can later be watched at home. The discussion concerns the place each viewing window occupies in the work’s identity and public circulation.

What changes when the experience is shared in a cinema

A screening brings together people who have set aside the same stretch of time to watch a film. The start, duration and finish are not at each viewer’s individual disposal. This can encourage greater concentration and make a long pause or an uncomfortable scene feel more intense, without the immediate option of switching to another title. It does not guarantee perfect attention, but it creates a shared setting.

The audience’s reactions are also part of that setting. Laughter can spread; silence can become noticeable when many people stop moving at the same time. Viewers retain their individual judgement, even as they sense that a scene is affecting other people in the room. The experience is not simply about receiving visual and aural information.

A theatrical release also provides a shared point in time. A film enters the conversation at a recognisable moment, with screenings, reviews and gatherings centred around its arrival. Platforms can also create collective events, but their ongoing availability shapes the relationship between release, discovery and continued presence differently. Confusing these forms of distribution makes it harder to discuss their specific advantages and limitations.

Home access offers real benefits that any case for cinemas must take into account. Not everyone lives near a varied film programme or can travel easily. Availability at home can bring a film to audiences who would not have been able to see it on release. Recognising this role does not mean treating the experiences as identical or abandoning the question of what is lost when an alternative disappears.

The Hateful Eight makes it impossible to speak of an outright rejection

In 2019, Tarantino explained to /Film his involvement in the episodic version of The Hateful Eight for Netflix. This introduces an important nuance: his criticism of releases designed for platforms cannot be turned into a claim that he has never worked with them. The film had already had a theatrical run before this new presentation.

This distinction helps us understand two different decisions. One is to conceive a work for theatrical release; another is to later revisit how it is distributed. The fact that both can coexist does not prove that the director approves of every platform production model. Nor does it automatically make any reservations he expresses inconsistent. To assess the relationship, we need to consider the specific project and the point at which he became involved.

Something similar applies to the idea of making television. An expression of interest, a possibility discussed in an interview and a completed project are different things. Turning any one of them into a firm promise can create artificial contradictions when conversations held years apart are compared. A filmmaker’s position may combine consistent preferences with specific decisions that need further context.

The phrase ‘war against Netflix’ oversimplifies this complexity and shifts the debate towards a personal feud. What deserves closer examination is what Tarantino considers necessary for the cinema he wants to make: a first public experience, a particular kind of attention and a relationship with the viewer’s memory. We can then discuss whether those conditions can exist only in cinemas, or whether they can also arise in other settings in a different way.

The case for theatrical exhibition becomes more concrete when it focuses on preserving the freedom to choose. A film may have an extended life at home and may first have needed a shared screen; another may find its audience mainly outside cinemas. Tarantino’s position gives priority to the first experience. Understanding that priority lets us discuss his arguments without automatically dismissing viewers who discover cinema through a platform.

See the guide to Tarantino’s books, criticism and film projects.

View all articles in Tarantino as a critic: books, podcasts and cinemas