Tarantino’s written reviews: how to read his film criticism

His critical writing lets readers follow a complete line of reasoning, with enthusiasms, objections and comparisons that a list of favourite films can only hint at.

An archive of signed writing, not just a collection of headlines

The Tarantino’s Reviews section on the New Beverly website brings together written criticism signed by Quentin Tarantino. It includes long-form essays and shorter formats, with dates and credits that are worth retaining. Not everything published on the cinema’s website is by him: news, programme announcements and articles by contributors serve different purposes. Identifying the author is the first step towards knowing what we are reading.

One example is American Graffiti, published on 29 June 2022. Tarantino places Lucas’s film alongside The Last Picture Show and Summer of ’42, and examines different forms of nostalgia. He also notes Curt’s reluctance to leave his community and raises reservations about Bo Hopkins’s casting. His overall admiration does not stop him from questioning a particular decision.

The text offers something that is lost when only an isolated sentence is shared: the chance to connect an assessment with the element of the film that prompts it. Readers can consider whether the example is convincing, whether the argument holds up and whether the objection really changes the judgement of the film as a whole. A review is valuable for this journey, as well as for the notability of the person who signs it.

From long-form essays to brief notes

The archive includes Grindhouse Mini Reviews, a collection of comments on exploitation films. The credits call for particular attention: some are signed by Tarantino, some by Jim or James Sheldon, and some are co-signed. The general heading of a page should not erase these distinctions. Sheldon’s identity has been the subject of conflicting attributions; when locating a text, it is best to retain the credit as published rather than resolve the issue by making an assumption.

The difference in length changes what readers can expect. A brief note can identify a memorable performance, a pacing problem or the appeal of a premise. An essay can develop comparisons and pause over a scene. Neither format is inherently better; what matters is whether the space available is enough to support what is being said. A forceful claim takes fewer words than the proof behind it.

The context of the New Beverly Cinema also influences how we read. A review can make us want to discover a film or watch it again in a particular print. This connection with film screenings does not make every text promotional. Criticism can guide audiences while still retaining the freedom to point out a failed interpretation or a construction that does not quite work.

It is also worth distinguishing a written review from an interview transcript. In the former, the author controls the flow of the text; in the latter, a question, an interruption or the rhythm of the conversation may explain a change of subject. Both are valuable sources, but they should not be presented as though they came about through the same process. The headline of a later news story adds yet another layer of selection.

How to make the most of his criticism

The review of The Lady in Red, shared by New Beverly and republished in February 2020, offers another starting point. Tarantino champions John Sayles’s screenplay for Lewis Teague’s film and places it among the most ambitious examples of exploitation cinema. His discussion of other screenwriters and films shows that this assessment needs a tradition of comparison, not just an enthusiastic adjective.

The example shifts attention to an area that lists of directors can leave in the background: who wrote a film and how its structure supports the characters. Reading it alongside American Graffiti makes it possible to compare two subjects of discussion: the shaping of a collective memory and the ambition of a story made within exploitation cinema. These are questions about specific films, not just the standing of their creators.

The archive also includes the essay Wang Yu: Superstar! Super Director!, dated 23 April 2020. Its title helps readers find a piece about a figure who combines acting and directing. Alongside Lucas and Teague, it broadens the discussion to different film industries and forms of action. The archive’s variety becomes clearer when its texts are identified, rather than turned into an undifferentiated list of recommendations.

Objections within a favourable review are particularly revealing. They show what matters most in the author’s assessment. A debatable performance may not ruin a film as a whole, while an apparently minor detail can change how believable a scene feels. Reading only negative criticism would turn a practice of assessment into an inventory of rejections; the page on films Tarantino has criticised belongs to that narrower category.

It is also useful to return to the film after reading the text. The argument may have drawn our attention to a reaction, a transition or a spatial relationship that we had missed. There is no need to reproduce the critic’s opinion when checking it against the film. Sometimes a second look confirms the observation and leads to a different assessment, because what one person sees as a flaw is part of the appeal for another.

His essays collected in Cinema Speculation offer another format for this conversation, with their own development and structure. Digital reviews retain their value as focused interventions, identifiable by title, author and date. The best way to use the archive is to move from opinion to film and back again with a more precise question, without treating the authority of an admired director as an obligation to agree with him.

See the guide to Tarantino’s books, criticism and cinephile projects.

View all articles in Tarantino as a critic: books, podcasts and cinemas