Tarantino’s so-called guilty pleasures: defending a film with nuance

The expression “guilty pleasure” suggests that enjoying certain films calls for an apology. Tarantino’s preferences give us a way to discuss that idea: he can defend a poorly received work, point out its flaws and find in it an experience that other viewers may not share.

The Lone Ranger: enthusiasm and objections in the same opinion

The Lone Ranger appeared on a provisional selection by Tarantino in 2013. In an interview with Les Inrockuptibles, translated by The Playlist on 10 October that year, he explained that he appreciated its opening and, especially, the train sequence. At the same time, he criticised the middle section and the way the massacre of Indigenous people was depicted.

The example is useful because it prevents us from presenting his defence as blind enthusiasm. A film can offer an extraordinary moment and contain choices that make the very same viewer uncomfortable. An assessment need not be reduced to a single, all-encompassing label. Recognising a successful scene does not mean excusing every problem with the film as a whole.

The railway sequence invites us to consider a very specific pleasure of adventure cinema: bodies and vehicles having to coordinate within a space in motion. The audience tracks positions, anticipates collisions and enjoys solutions that seem impossible until the images make them comprehensible. This kind of inventiveness can appeal even to someone who has reservations about the story.

The objection to the depiction of Indigenous people introduces another dimension of judgement. A scene’s effectiveness does not rule out questioning what is turned into entertainment, or whose perspective it takes. Tarantino’s comment shows that formal admiration and criticism of a portrayal can coexist.

That is why it is imprecise to sum up his position as a love of objectively bad cinema. The word “objectively” erases precisely the space for discussion. There may be identifiable mistakes or unconvincing choices, but a film-going experience cannot be reduced to a collective rating or its box-office figures.

Kick-Ass 2 and paying attention to a particular approach

In the same 2013 exchange, Tarantino praised Jeff Wadlow’s approach as writer and director of Kick-Ass 2. Including the title among his preferences did not amount to an unreserved recommendation of every superhero film. He was referring to one particular work, with its own tone and choices.

Kick-Ass 2 works with the clash between a fantasy of heroic identity and a reality that brings physical and emotional consequences. Its shifts in tone may appeal to one viewer and put off another. Critical discussion begins precisely when we try to explain this effect, rather than simply noting that some of the audience rejected it.

Defending a genre film does not require pretending that it occupies the same place as every other work. One can appreciate its energy, a performance choice or the way it combines different registers. The argument is more useful when it names these elements than when it treats disagreement as automatic proof of superior film knowledge.

The date must also be kept in mind. A provisional selection from 2013 reflects a particular moment of viewing and the films available up to then. It is not necessarily the definitive assessment of the year or a list Tarantino kept unchanged. The context prevents a passing enthusiasm from becoming an eternal declaration.

Anything Else and the freedom to disagree

Anything Else appeared on Tarantino’s list published by L.A. Weekly in August 2009. The choice gives us a chance to discuss a preference that often surprises people, but it does not prove that the film is a guilty pleasure for him. “Guilt” is a label added by someone who believes that this taste needs an explanation.

Woody Allen’s comedy, released in 2003, offers a look at relationships shaped by insecurity, dependence and unreliable advice. Its effect depends largely on how much the viewer enjoys spending time with characters who talk about their problems without easily resolving them. That pleasure can exist even when the protagonists’ behaviour is irritating.

The difference between liking someone and enjoying a film is relevant to many of Tarantino’s preferences. A character need not be someone we would want to live with for a scene to hold our interest. A distinctive voice, an awkward situation or a contradiction can make an unpleasant presence compelling.

For example, repeating advice that is never followed can create comedy out of failure. The scene is interesting because it lets us recognise a behaviour, even though it offers neither an admirable example nor a solution for the audience to imitate.

These choices do not make the director an automatic defender of every film that is dismissed. Going against the grain can be just as mechanical as always following the consensus. What makes a recommendation interesting is its specific connection with the work and the ability to explain what one finds in it.

The Lone Ranger, Kick-Ass 2 and Anything Else offer different experiences, brought together here by the disagreement they can provoke. Watching them does not require adopting Tarantino’s judgement in advance. Their value as recommendations lies in opening up the possibility of paying closer attention: pausing over a scene, listening to a tone or finding out whether a flaw really prevents all enjoyment.

See the selection of films recommended by Tarantino.

View all articles in Films recommended by Tarantino: sources and selections