Films criticised by Tarantino: what he said and what he hadn’t seen

Tarantino’s criticisms often circulate as lists of films he hates. To understand them, it’s important to distinguish between a negative opinion after watching a film, a partial objection and the decision not to watch something: these are different situations and lead to different conclusions.

Natural Born Killers and a personal connection to the screenplay

In his 2019 BAFTA conversation, Tarantino expressed his dislike of the film Natural Born Killers and distinguished it from his appreciation of his own screenplay. The distinction is central: here he wasn’t discussing someone else’s work with the usual distance of a viewer, but the transformation of material he had written.

The film, released in 1994, was directed by Oliver Stone. Its visual experience, with changes in format, an overload of imagery and an insistent satire of media spectacle, belongs to that production. Tarantino’s authorship of the original story doesn’t make the result a film directed by him, nor does it mean that the two necessarily shared the same creative decisions.

The disagreement helps explain why the film frequently appears in these compilations. However, there’s no need to invent a story of personal animosity to explain the criticism. Nor does it justify identifying any scene a viewer dislikes as a specific change made by Stone without comparing the relevant versions of the text.

The Last Crusade: an unusual preference

In August 2022, during his appearance on ReelBlend, Tarantino said he preferred Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull to Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade. CinemaBlend published the comment on 12 August. His objection was to the boredom he felt during the third instalment and the way Sean Connery’s character worked.

It’s an opinion about the 1989 film and its father-and-son dynamic. It doesn’t prove that he rejects all sequels or considers Spielberg’s entire career a failure. A filmmaker can admire one of a director’s adventures and disagree with a follow-up that other viewers prefer.

The Last Crusade shifts some of the focus from exploration to the family relationship. For those who enjoy that relationship, the interruptions and arguments may be among the film’s greatest attractions. According to that comment, Tarantino didn’t get the same result from this approach. The disagreement is personal criticism; it doesn’t change the film’s content or make majority taste an obligation.

Moreover, comparing two instalments isn’t the same as providing a comprehensive ranking. A favourable comment about The Kingdom of the Crystal Skull compared with The Last Crusade leaves other questions open: which scenes he appreciates, how much he likes it overall, or where he might place all the films in the series at another time.

Refusing to watch Dune or Toy Story 4 isn’t reviewing them

In October 2024, his conversation with Bret Easton Ellis about the new adaptations of Dune was shared. Tarantino explained that he hadn’t seen them because he already knew one version of that story and didn’t feel the need to revisit it. The same discussion included Ripley and Shōgun. This was a statement about his choices as a viewer, not an analysis of scenes from works he said he hadn’t seen.

Something similar applies to Toy Story 4. In his 2024 conversation with Bill Maher, he defended the ending of the previous trilogy and said he didn’t want to continue. Presenting that refusal as a detailed criticism of the fourth film would add a judgement that his words don’t contain. Preferring to preserve an ending doesn’t prove that a continuation has no merit.

General opinions about remakes, franchises or digital effects shouldn’t automatically be turned into verdicts on every title in those categories either. A comment about an industry trend can coexist with exceptions. To include a film in a selection of works he rejects, there needs to be a statement about that film, not merely an association with the type of cinema he criticises.

The documented examples show different degrees of rejection: Natural Born Killers involves a break with the adaptation of his writing; The Last Crusade receives criticism based on having watched it; and Dune and Toy Story 4 are films he chose not to seek out. Maintaining these distinctions prevents a striking list from attributing opinions to him that he never expressed.

See the selection of films recommended by Tarantino.

View all articles in Films recommended by Tarantino: sources and selections