Remakes admired by Tarantino: praise doesn’t always mean preference

The search for remakes that Tarantino considers better than the original rests on an assumption worth checking. His admiration for a new version does not, by itself, prove that he compared it with the earlier one and declared it the winner.

The Thing: a clear reference, a different comparison

Tarantino told Time Out in January 2016 that John Carpenter’s The Thing had been a key reference for The Hateful Eight and Reservoir Dogs. That comment confirms an important influence. It does not, however, include an explicit ranking that places the 1982 film above The Thing from Another World, from 1951.

The distinction makes it possible to discuss the films precisely. Both films are linked to John W. Campbell’s story Who Goes There?, but they handle the danger and the creature’s identity differently. A critical comparison can examine those choices. To present it as Tarantino’s opinion, though, we would need a statement from him addressing that very relationship.

In Carpenter’s version, the creature’s ability to imitate others makes the group unsafe from within. The problem is not simply defending a base against a recognisable being. That quality explains why The Thing is useful as a model of suspicion and confinement, as explored in the profile of John Carpenter and his relationship with Tarantino.

Sorcerer and new adaptations of the same source

William Friedkin’s Sorcerer featured in Tarantino’s 2012 Sight and Sound poll. Its inclusion documents his enthusiasm for the 1977 film, but does not amount to saying he prefers it to Henri-Georges Clouzot’s The Wages of Fear. Their shared literary source makes the comparison relevant; the list alone does not settle it.

Friedkin also described his film as a new interpretation of Georges Arnaud’s novel. The oral history published by the Cinémathèque française in March 2024 records this view. The word remake can be useful in general conversation, although it does not fully capture the relationship between two films that revisit the same source.

Nor do the statements compared here reveal a comparative preference from Tarantino that would allow Invasion of the Body Snatchers to be placed in a ranking of remakes superior to their originals. Including it because other filmmakers have praised it would transfer one person’s opinion to another. A good selection needs to preserve who made each assessment.

A new version is not a sequel

A remake revisits a story; a sequel continues a story or brings back characters for another adventure. The distinction can become complicated with franchise reboots, but it remains useful for keeping the questions separate. Comments about sequels Tarantino rates highly do not automatically prove that he has a theory about new adaptations.

His public refusal in 2024 to watch the new Dune films does not establish an aesthetic rule that applies to every era, either. He was expressing fatigue with stories he already knew. His documented admiration for The Thing and Sorcerer shows, at the very least, that his preferences cannot be explained by a simple rule such as rejecting every film with a predecessor.

The verifiable answer, then, is a limited selection of new versions he appreciates, together with the precise scope of the evidence for each. A comparison of their quality with the originals remains open when he has not made one in an identifiable source. Turning that absence into a definitive ranking would claim a certainty the available testimony does not provide.

See the selection of films recommended by Tarantino.

View all articles in Films recommended by Tarantino: sources and selections