Vanilla Fudge at the climax: an extended song for sudden violence

You Keep Me Hangin’ On plays during the climax of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood in Vanilla Fudge’s version. The arrangement’s density and shifts in intensity contribute to a scene that blends menace, absurdity and violence.

A version that changes the song’s nature

You Keep Me Hangin’ On was written by Holland-Dozier-Holland and popularised by The Supremes before Vanilla Fudge recorded their version. The rock group’s recording was released in 1967, turning the song into a longer, heavier and more psychedelic interpretation. Once Upon a Time in Hollywood uses this transformation, so identifying the title alone is not enough to explain what we hear during the climax.

The difference can be heard in the way the song handles time. Vanilla Fudge stretches out phrases, adds considerable instrumental weight and builds a sense of pressure that doesn’t rely on a steady pace. The song can progress through build-ups and contrasts, making the wait as important as the release. This flexibility gives the editing a musical form that can accompany abrupt shifts in energy.

The official album lists the track as Quentin Tarantino Edit and gives it a duration of five minutes. That designation identifies a specific edit, not a new songwriting credit. The composers and performers retain their credits, while the album presentation acknowledges the adaptation. This track shouldn’t be confused with any version of the single or with a complete replay of every version the group released.

The voice and organ contribute to an atmosphere that can feel agonising. Here, the song doesn’t work as cheerful music placed over terrible images to create a simple contrast. Its own intensity already contains tension. The relationship between music and violence is more variable: at times they reinforce each other, while elsewhere the action’s exaggeration introduces a comic distance that isn’t inherent in the recording.

The confrontation disrupts a domestic routine

The attackers burst into a space the film has shown as a home, a place for conversation and rest. The music contributes to the change in what that setting represents. Everyday objects no longer belong solely to a familiar routine; they become part of a chaotic action. Viewers can find their bearings because they already know some of the house, even as the violence makes its uses and movements unpredictable.

Cliff encounters the situation in an altered state that affects the tone of the meeting. The way he speaks and recognises the visitors introduces a strange delay before the confrontation. The scene can seem dangerous and absurd at the same time. Vanilla Fudge’s weight helps sustain a pressure that doesn’t quite match the character’s apparent calm, so the sound retains a sense of menace even when the dialogue gets a laugh.

Brandy’s intervention abruptly shifts the balance of power. The film has already established her life with Cliff, and that memory makes it easier to follow some of the action. The music accompanies the outbreak of violence, but it doesn’t replace the concrete sounds of the confrontation. Shouts, blows and movement are still needed to give the sequence a physical presence and let the audience perceive its changes of direction.

Nor does the editing turn every act of aggression into an exact illustration of a lyric. The relationship works mainly through intensity, duration and accents. A musical phrase can extend across several shots, while a visual blow interrupts an expectation created by the sound. This irregular coordination keeps the violence from feeling like an overly neat rhythmic display. The scene retains a friction between the musical form and the disorder of what’s happening.

From the living room to the pool: different experiences of the same danger

Rick Dalton is initially apart from the main confrontation. This separation lets the scene distribute knowledge unevenly: viewers have seen events that Rick doesn’t yet understand. The climax music is part of our overall experience, while each character perceives different fragments of the danger. We shouldn’t assume that everyone hears the same song with equal clarity within the fictional world.

When the action reaches the pool, the actor’s refuge takes on a different meaning. The place of leisure becomes connected to the violence inside and to an object from his film work. The result blends physical abilities, memories of filming and a fairy-tale-like exaggeration. The song contributes to the emotional build-up, but understanding the turn also depends on elements the story introduced much earlier.

The film’s alternate ending shifts the expectations of anyone familiar with the historical murders. The violence leads to a different outcome, and the music contributes to the intensity of that departure. This doesn’t make the musical sequence a sufficient moral explanation of what happens. The pleasure, rejection or unease the scene provokes depends on how each viewer responds to the combination of historical memory and cinematic fantasy.

Heard within the official soundtrack, Vanilla Fudge’s edit lets us recognise how it is constructed without the images. Back in the film, that same structure is intersected by bodies, interruptions and changes of setting. The comparison shows how much an existing song can do when adapted for a sequence: it retains its performance and musical history, while acquiring new associations through the editing and the information built up over the course of the film.

More context in the Once Upon a Time in Hollywood guide.

View all articles in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood: characters, city and cinema