The deleted Manson scene: his conversation with Paul Barabuta

The deleted footage extends Charles Manson’s visit to Cielo Drive. His conversation is with Paul Barabuta, played by Danny Strong, and the scene changes how long we spend watching Damon Herriman’s character.

Paul Barabuta, not Paul Revere

The deleted conversation from Once Upon a Time in Hollywood brings Damon Herriman’s Charles Manson together with Paul Barabuta, played by Danny Strong. It is not an encounter with Paul Revere, the musician from Paul Revere & The Raiders. The shared name and the band’s presence in the film may cause confusion, but the person Manson speaks to has a different role in the scene: he is the property owner Manson approaches while looking for Terry Melcher.

The footage extends a visit that appears briefly in the released cut. Manson arrives at Cielo Drive and asks for people who no longer live there. The extended version follows him to the guest house and lets us hear a longer conversation. The scene ends by visually connecting him with Cliff Booth, who is working on the roof of Rick’s house. That spatial continuity belongs to the fiction created by Tarantino.

The filmed dialogue should not be presented as a historical transcript of a verified conversation. The scene uses names and places associated with real events, but arranges them within a story that includes Rick and Cliff, two fictional characters. Recognising this distinction makes it possible to analyse the performance without treating it as documentary evidence of the exact words Manson said during a real visit.

What Herriman’s performance gains

In a 2026 interview, Damon Herriman explained that the guest-house scene had been used for his audition and later appeared among the bonus material. He also distinguished its tone from the imprisoned Manson he played in Mindhunter. The actor’s observation helps explain that Tarantino’s version has moments of comic awkwardness, as well as the menace audiences associate with the character’s name.

The conversation shows an everyday frustration: Manson is looking for a contact and doesn’t get the response he wants. The rejection interrupts the impression of authority he can wield over his followers. Outside that circle, he has to ask, wait and accept limits imposed by others. The scene uses this change of scale to show an irritating presence rather than an all-powerful figure able to dominate any space he enters.

The brief appearance of Manson in the theatrical cut has a different effect. By giving him less screen time, the film lets much of the menace come from what the audience already knows. The deleted footage adds behaviour, voice and a specific interaction. The two approaches distribute attention differently: one keeps his appearance abrupt, while the other lets us examine how the character tries to handle a social situation.

An extra that changes the balance of the visit

The visual encounter with Cliff connects the historical visitor with one of the fictional protagonists. It is not proof that the two share a prior relationship, nor does it by itself show that Cliff understands the significance of the person in front of him. The look creates a closeness that the audience can invest with meaning, thanks to what it knows. This difference between the audience’s knowledge and the character’s knowledge is one of the sequence’s devices.

Watching the footage separately lets us appreciate the performance without assuming that its absence from the cut means it was not good enough. A scene can work on its own and still shift a character’s prominence too much within the whole film. Here, extending the visit gives Manson attention that the theatrical release distributed differently. We can analyse the effect without attributing a specific reason for the scene’s removal to the director unless there is a statement confirming it.

Nor is the scene equivalent to the expansions in the Once Upon a Time in Hollywood novel. The extra preserves an audiovisual performance; the book works through written narration. Comparing them means respecting their different versions and avoiding lumping them together as if they were all part of a secret, already-edited film. What can be verified is more specific: an extended version of the visit was filmed, Barabuta is the person Manson speaks to, and the encounter reveals a side of Herriman that the initial cut left out.

More context in the Once Upon a Time in Hollywood guide.

View all articles in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood: characters, city and cinema