Tarantino’s Sight and Sound votes: 2002 and 2012

The Sight and Sound lists make it possible to compare preferences expressed ten years apart. Tarantino included twelve titles, and his choices should not be confused with the magazine’s collective ranking.

Two personal selections within a larger poll

Sight and Sound periodically gathers votes from critics and filmmakers to compile its polls of great films. Individual responses and aggregated results are separate documents. A film appearing in Tarantino’s selection does not mean it holds the same position in the results from all directors, and another film winning the poll does not make it his personal favourite.

The historical selections attributed to Tarantino for 2002 and 2012 each contain twelve titles. The usual label of “top ten” should not mean removing two entries just to make the document fit a more convenient format. Nor should a list be completed with films taken from a different interview when a specific selection already makes it possible to identify what he voted for.

The 2002 selection includes The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, Rio Bravo, Taxi Driver, His Girl Friday, Rolling Thunder, They All Laughed, The Great Escape, Carrie, Coffy, Dazed and Confused, Five Fingers of Death and Hi Diddle Diddle. The mix brings together westerns, comedy, crime films and martial arts, as well as works with very different levels of circulation and prestige.

The 2012 selection includes The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, Apocalypse Now, The Bad News Bears, Carrie, Dazed and Confused, The Great Escape, His Girl Friday, Jaws, Pretty Maids All in a Row, Rolling Thunder, Sorcerer and Taxi Driver. The selection retains several elements of the earlier one and adds other titles, without thereby amounting to a repudiation of everything that was left out.

The recurring titles reveal a sense of continuity

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly holds a prominent place in Tarantino’s public cinephilia and appears in both selections. Sergio Leone’s film combines epic scale, characters defined through their actions and an extraordinary attention to waiting. The final duel shows how looks, distance and music can shape a scene before it is resolved with a decisive gesture.

His Girl Friday offers a very different experience, built around the rapid-fire exchanges and relationships negotiated through words. Its presence alongside Leone’s film makes it impossible to reduce these lists to an exclusive fascination with violence. Verbal energy and the building of groups are also part of the films chosen, even though each handles them with different tools.

Dazed and Confused and The Great Escape invite us to consider how a large ensemble cast can work together. One follows youthful encounters and comings and goings; the other organizes a collective undertaking in a place of confinement. Comparing them does not mean their stories are equivalent. It helps us recognize the interest in watching distinct characters share a space, and how a film distributes our attention among them.

Carrie, Taxi Driver and Rolling Thunder introduce forms of isolation and violence that should not be grouped together as if they offered the same moral explanation. Each work constructs its own point of view, setting and journey. The list documents admiration; analysing what these films do requires preserving their differences rather than turning them into illustrations of a single voter’s personality.

Changes do not amount to a list of disowned films

Rio Bravo and Coffy appear in the 2002 selection but not the 2012 one. That absence does not prove that Tarantino stopped appreciating them. A poll requires voters to choose from a limited number of titles, and a response can change because of revisiting films, associations or priorities at the time. To claim a later rejection, we would need a statement identifying it as such.

The additions in 2012 also broaden the range. Sorcerer builds tension around transporting a dangerous cargo; Apocalypse Now develops a wartime journey on a very different scale and in a very different style. The Bad News Bears uses a sports team and comedy to explore relationships between adults and children. The collection does not propose a single recipe for excellence. Dazed and Confused, for example, finds value in moving from one encounter to another; Sorcerer concentrates much of its pressure on a physical task. Their running times serve very different narrative needs.

The 2012 list should not be labelled a 2022 vote simply because it appears on an updated page or in a recent compilation. The dates are part of the document’s meaning. They show which point in the director’s career we are looking at and prevent preferences from different decades from being mixed together under a supposedly definitive, ever-current ranking.

To use these votes as a viewing guide, it helps to keep both the selection and its context. We can compare recurring films, discover less familiar titles and see what changes between the two responses. The poll offers a snapshot of expressed preferences, not an obligation to reproduce them. Its value lies in opening conversations about the works and showing that even a very recognizable taste includes comedy, adventure, horror and different ways of spending time with characters.

Back to movies recommended by Tarantino.

View all articles in Films Recommended by Tarantino: Sources and Selections