What Tarantino criticised about Marvel and its stars

The controversy did not begin with a review of a particular film. Tarantino was discussing who attracts audiences and how much space a franchise occupies in Hollywood’s imagination.

The November 2022 conversation

Quentin Tarantino spoke about Marvel’s transformation of Hollywood on the episode of 2 Bears, 1 Cave with Tom Segura, published on 21 November 2022. The conversation coincided with the promotion of Cinema Speculation. His comments addressed the prominence of franchises and the concept of a film star, rather than offering a detailed assessment of the direction of each film from the studio.

The example he used contrasted performers with characters: he felt that audiences went to see Captain America or Thor rather than Chris Evans or Chris Hemsworth in their own right. This did not amount to denying that the actors were well known. His argument was that the character’s brand concentrated the drawing power that, in another model of Hollywood, he associated with the star.

He also expressed discomfort with the sense that this kind of film dominated the industry’s conversation and enthusiasm. In the version reported by the media, the problem was that these films seemed to represent an entire era. This is a critical and deliberately emphatic perception; it should not be turned into the literal claim that no other kind of cinema was made in 2022.

The distinction between these two levels matters. A statement about what seems to occupy the centre of the market can open up a cultural discussion; demonstrating production, distribution or investment shares requires different data. Tarantino was offering a judgement on the landscape he saw, not a statistical report on all Hollywood budgets.

Actor, character and franchise are not the same

At the heart of the debate is whether audience interest can be carried from one role to another. A star, in the classical sense Tarantino assumes, retains the power to attract audiences beyond one particular fictional identity. A franchise preserves some of its appeal through a character, a universe and the expectation of continuity, even when an element of the cast changes.

Both mechanisms can coexist. A viewer can be interested in a hero while also feeling that the hero’s appeal is inseparable from the performance they know. A character’s fame does not make all performances interchangeable. Nor does an actor’s popularity guarantee that every project outside the franchise will draw the same audience. The difficulty lies in measuring how much each component contributes.

Samuel L. Jackson responded on The View on 29 November 2022. He defended the importance of actors in bringing these characters to life and pointed to Chadwick Boseman as an example that challenged a strict separation between the two. His response showed a genuine disagreement between colleagues: admiring Tarantino’s work did not mean accepting his definition of a star without question.

Jackson’s objection can be understood through the relationship audiences build with a performance. The character exists as a design, a name and a story, but the actor’s voice, gestures and presence contribute to its meaning. That observation does not, by itself, settle the industry debate; it does, however, make it necessary to avoid letting an explanation based on brands erase the work that makes those brands memorable.

On the other hand, Tarantino’s question does not disappear just because a performance is excellent. The fact that someone is very good in one role does not automatically determine how much scope they will have afterwards to lead different projects. Both questions can be considered together: artistic recognition and the ability to attract audiences beyond a familiar property.

What this means for films with other budgets

The concern about concentration has implications that can be examined without attributing a non-existent economic essay to Tarantino. When a large share of promotional attention is organised around continuing universes, standalone films have to find other ways to be seen. A thriller, an adult comedy or a drama cannot necessarily promise the next chapter of a story audiences already know.

That does not prove that Marvel is the sole cause of the difficulties faced by mid-budget cinema. Distribution, viewing habits, financing and the relationship with streaming platforms raise broader issues. Treating a line from the podcast as sufficient proof of a single cause would oversimplify both the industry and the director’s own position.

Nor should the statements be attributed to him without qualification as if they were the same as the views of Martin Scorsese or other filmmakers. They may share concerns about market concentration while making different arguments. In this conversation, Tarantino emphasised stars and the dominant representation of an era. That context makes it possible to discuss what he said without turning him into a spokesperson for every criticism of superhero cinema.

The disagreement is more useful when it stays focused on specific questions: what makes a film recognisable, what role the actor plays, and how much room a work that starts from scratch can find. The 2022 statements do not offer a definitive answer, but they do present a clear position that can be compared with the experiences of other viewers, performers and filmmakers.

Return to Tarantino’s books, criticism and film projects.

View all articles in Tarantino as a critic: books, podcasts and cinemas