Pauline Kael and Tarantino: learning to watch by reading criticism

Tarantino has explained that Pauline Kael’s phrases eventually became part of his memory. Her influence helps us understand criticism as an experience that stays with the viewer after the book is closed.

A filmgoer who became a point of reference

Pauline Kael began publishing in The New Yorker in 1967 and became the magazine’s film critic in 1968, following her defence of Bonnie and Clyde. She continued there until retiring in 1991. Her writing was collected in books such as I Lost It at the Movies and Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, making it possible to read her judgements beyond the week-to-week news cycle.

For Quentin Tarantino, that writing was a lasting point of reference. In a conversation with Lynn Hirschberg published on 29 January 2020 as part of Five Things, he explained that he had read so much Kael that her ideas and phrases came to mind spontaneously. The recollection describes an influence absorbed into memory, not simply distant admiration for a prestigious figure.

The difference is significant. A critic can recommend a film and disappear from the subsequent experience. They can also offer a way to ask questions about it: what an actor is doing, where the tone shifts or why a scene feels stimulating. In the latter case, reading changes how we pay attention, even when the viewer no longer remembers which article an observation came from.

There is no need to turn this relationship into face-to-face teaching. Reading an author over many years allows for sustained learning without a course, a tutor or approval of every future work. Kael’s documented influence on Tarantino belongs above all to reading and to the way of thinking about cinema that reading made possible.

Pleasure as a starting point for criticism

Kael championed writing that could recognise the pleasure of popular cinema without demanding an air of solemnity from it. Value could be found in a performance, a rhythm or a blend of tones that an existing classification had relegated to lesser entertainment. This outlook helps explain why her name is so relevant when discussing a filmmaker who pays attention to films across widely differing genres and reputations.

A concrete example can be found in the relationship with Bande à part, by Jean-Luc Godard. A recollection published by Air Mail in November 2022 recalls the impact Kael’s description of the poetic transformation of a popular crime story had on Tarantino. The interest lay in what a film could discover within material considered vulgar, rather than abandoning that material to gain respectability.

The lesson can be framed as a question for the reader: what does this scene achieve that its plot summary cannot explain? Saying that two characters talk or that someone runs away barely describes what happens. The actor’s voice, an interruption, the length of a pause or another character’s reaction can make it something quite different. Criticism becomes useful when it makes that difference perceptible.

In 2022, David Bordwell linked Tarantino’s criticism with Kael’s on account of its attention to acting, dialogue, genre and audience response. This affinity does not mean that they judge every film in the same way. It points to shared ground: the viewer’s experience matters, and enthusiasm for a scene can begin an argument rather than appear only as a final verdict.

Describing this style as anti-academic calls for care. A lively voice does not remove the need for precise observation; a colloquial phrase can contain a complex distinction. Likewise, a provocative tone does not by itself guarantee an insightful opinion. What is interesting about the relationship is not replacing analysis with spontaneity, but keeping the person who is watching in view.

Influence, disagreement and a voice of one’s own

The relationship is especially clear in Cinema Speculation, where Tarantino blends memory, commentary on films and speculation. The reader hears a voice that makes no attempt to hide its preferences. This choice makes it possible to discuss them directly: we know what excites the author, what irritates him and the experiences from which he frames some of his questions.

The risk of such personal writing is that verbal confidence may seem sufficient proof. A brilliant judgement can point to something real or impose an impression that is too quick. Reading Kael and then Tarantino is more productive if we retain the freedom to disagree. Admiration does not require us to adopt every dismissal or defend a film out of loyalty to the critic.

The distance between criticism and filmmaking also matters. A filmmaker can learn from a review without transferring it literally to a scene. Words shape questions; films need to resolve them through images, sound and performances. There is no automatic equivalence between an admired phrase and a specific production decision, and attributing one requires more than recognising a similar tone.

To begin exploring this influence, it is worth reading one of Kael’s reviews of a familiar film and comparing her observations with your own experience. Then you can compare it with a chapter by Tarantino on another, related title. The relationship then emerges through specific approaches: how they describe a performance, how they justify pleasure and how much space they allow for the disagreement a film provokes.

Return to Tarantino’s books, criticism and film projects.

View all articles in Tarantino as a critic: books, podcasts and cinemas