Tarantino included The Wild Bunch in a discussion of films that are almost impossible to fault, while acknowledging its imperfections. That mix of enthusiasm and reservation offers a way to approach Sam Peckinpah without reducing his work to a celebration of bloodshed.
Praise that doesn’t erase the flaws
During his appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live in October 2022, Tarantino spoke about films he considered perfect. When he added The Wild Bunch, he qualified his praise: he didn’t consider it technically perfect, but its power seemed hard to dispute. NME and other media outlets reported on the comments. That distinction avoids turning the praise into a literal claim that every element of the film is flawless.
Released in 1969, The Wild Bunch follows a group of men whose way of life seems to be nearing its end. The toll is not only physical. Their codes of loyalty must survive in a world of financial interests, guns and forces greater than themselves. The violence arises from that situation and the decisions they make within it.
The film doesn’t need to portray its protagonists as exemplary people for their fate to matter. We can recognise bonds, memories and contradictions without absolving them of every act. That ambivalence makes the audience’s identification with them less stable than a simple division between heroes and villains.
Tarantino’s observation about imperfection is a useful starting point for criticism. Some films draw their power from the friction between elements that don’t fit together neatly. Their greatness can coexist with excesses, uncomfortable moments and debatable choices. Admiring them doesn’t require us to erase that tension.
The editing of violence and the perception of the body
In The Wild Bunch’s major sequences, violence doesn’t appear as a uniform action that we can follow at a single speed. Changes in scale and duration fragment our perception. A movement is interrupted, a body falls, another position enters our field of attention. The editing turns the clash into an experience of time as well as space.
Slow motion lets us perceive harm differently, but it doesn’t work in isolation from everything else. Its effect depends on the contrast with faster images and the accumulation of different viewpoints. The viewer can feel both fascination with the form and revulsion at what it shows.
Calling violence poetic shouldn’t be a way to erase its victims. The adjective can describe the shaping of rhythm and image, but it also risks making suffering decorative. In The Wild Bunch, the density of bodies, noise and destruction makes it difficult to maintain an entirely untroubled relationship with the spectacle.
Space, too, is no longer a neutral playing field. People occupy positions that change with every shot, and the collective scale means not every death receives the same attention. That unevenness of perception is part of what makes the sequence uncomfortable: the spectacle can overwhelm our ability to register individually what is happening.
These observations describe Peckinpah’s editing; they shouldn’t be turned into a supposed technical argument by Tarantino. His documented praise gives us a way into the film. Examining its images then lets us discuss what that violence does and why it remains difficult to reduce to a single response.
Loyalty, the end of an era and a shared decision
The bond between the men gives weight to their final actions. A march or a brief exchange can hold decisions that no longer need to be explained in a long speech. The group has built up a history of losses and commitments; the viewer senses that weight in the way they walk and recognise one another.
Their code of loyalty doesn’t resolve all their contradictions. It can prompt a gesture of solidarity while coexisting with cruelty, opportunism or contempt for those left outside the group. The film allows this group morality to retain its dramatic appeal without turning it into a universal ethic the audience must accept.
Their tired faces give that code a physical dimension. Experience can bring skill, but it also leaves signs of wear that no heroic declaration can erase. We sense the characters’ time running out before anyone explains it.
There is also a difference between the nobility the characters imagine for themselves and the material reality of what they do. Money, guns and survival don’t disappear when they invoke their principles. That mixture keeps them from becoming abstract emblems of a lost West. Their world may be coming to an end, but it remains deeply violent.
Tarantino’s admiration for Peckinpah encompasses other registers. In his 2019 BAFTA conversation, he mentioned Junior Bonner as a film he returns to for its characters. That brief reference is a reminder that this affinity isn’t based solely on blood-soaked editing, and that a director’s career can offer very different pleasures.
The Wild Bunch remains a particularly intense example because it doesn’t easily separate affection for the men from horror at their actions. The audience can mourn their fate while also recognising the harm that accompanies it. That tension gives meaning to Tarantino’s qualified praise in 2022: a film can retain extraordinary power without becoming a flawless or comfortable object.
Explore our selection of filmmakers and actors admired by Tarantino.
View all articles in The filmmakers and performers Quentin Tarantino admires
