Corbucci’s devotion has a precise formulation: Tarantino presents him as the second great director of the Italian western, behind Leone.
What second place really means
In the documentary Django & Django, directed by Luca Rea and released in 2021, Quentin Tarantino discusses his admiration for Sergio Corbucci. The description from distributor Shameless Films places him as the second-best director of Italian westerns. The adjective matters: this is not a proven ranking of every western filmmaker in the world, nor a claim that automatically puts him ahead of every American director.
There is also an earlier record of this preference. In the list Tarantino gave The Spaghetti Western Database in January 2009, Django ranked third and The Great Silence fourteenth. Both choices show a sustained interest in Corbucci, although a film’s place on a personal list does not, by itself, explain the reasons for that admiration. To understand them, it helps to look at the kind of West his images create.
Corbucci offers an entry into a territory where violence can be embedded in institutions, the economy and everyday life. The protagonist does not always arrive in a community that can regain its balance simply by getting rid of a villain. Sometimes the community is organised in such a way that cruelty pays. That difference changes what we expect when a gunslinger appears.
Django: the hero arrives dragging a coffin
Django, released in 1966, shows Franco Nero crossing a muddy landscape with a coffin. The image defines a strange relationship between movement and burden: the character keeps going, but carries something belonging to the world of the dead. Before we know what he intends, his presence already raises a question. The mystery does not depend on an immediate verbal explanation; it is built into a visible action and an object impossible to ignore.
The mud also transforms the texture of the western. The ground makes it hard to move, soils bodies and strips journeys of their nobility. The spaces seem worn and hostile. The landscape is not a promise of limitless freedom, but a substance weighing on those trying to cross it. This physical experience sets the scene for a story in which the hero’s superiority cannot be taken for granted either.
The violence of the opposing groups places the protagonist within a system of domination and opportunism. Getting involved does not mean finding a morally transparent side to join without reservation. The viewer has to follow the alliances and distinguish between what the character says and what he is trying to achieve. The lone gunslinger remains compelling, but his journey is shaped by interests that do not disappear after a display of skill.
The body’s vulnerability is essential. A gunslinger is often defined by the speed and skill of his hands; threatening them calls into question the identity the genre gives him. Corbucci makes violence affect the very ability to act. The tension is not just about waiting for the next duel, but asking what remains of a hero when he loses some of what made him formidable.
The Great Silence and the fragility of justice
The relationship between landscape and body makes it possible to compare the two films without reducing their differences to their plots: walking through mud and moving across snow create different, visible forms of resistance.
The Great Silence, from 1968, swaps mud for snow and pits Jean-Louis Trintignant against Klaus Kinski. The cold is not a pleasant backdrop to the action. It shapes movement, isolation and dependence on scarce shelter. Nor does the white landscape offer an equivalent moral clarity: a clean appearance can conceal a profoundly cruel order.
The bounty system turns death into paid work. The law can provide cover for those who profit from pursuing vulnerable people. This makes the conflict harder to resolve through a simple opposition between law enforcers and criminals. The viewer needs to consider who gains power from the rules and who is left exposed to them.
The silent protagonist shifts our attention to gestures, glances and the relationships he forms with others. His reserve does not eliminate emotion, but requires us to sense it without constant explanatory speeches. Opposite him, the antagonist’s confidence is unsettling because it seems to rest on something more solid than his individual skill: an environment that tolerates and rewards his behaviour.
Without revealing the ending, the film shows just how much the western needs to promise that justice is possible. Corbucci puts that expectation under pressure, forcing us to recognise the distance between wanting redress and having the means to achieve it. Tarantino’s admiration finds here a cinema that can be spectacular and abrasive, recognisable as adventure yet difficult to accept as consolation. Watching Django alongside The Great Silence lets us appreciate two variations on that harshness without reducing the director to a single image of violence.
Explore the selection of filmmakers and actors admired by Tarantino.
View all articles in The filmmakers and performers Quentin Tarantino admires
