Cinema Speculation: how Tarantino reads 1970s cinema

Cinema Speculation blends memoir and criticism. Tarantino revisits films that shaped his development to discuss how they work and how they might have been different.

A book about cinema, built from experience

Cinema Speculation was published in English on 1 November 2022 by Harper. It is a work of non-fiction, distinct from the novelisation of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. Its structure is based around American films, mainly from the 1970s, combining personal memories, critical judgements and questions about the decisions that shaped those works.

The contents give a sense of the book’s scope without mistaking it for a comprehensive history of the decade. It includes chapters on Bullitt, Dirty Harry, Deliverance, The Getaway, The Outfit, Taxi Driver and Rolling Thunder, among other titles. It ranges from the late sixties to The Funhouse, from 1981. These dates frame the development of a filmgoer, rather than a neatly defined period.

That distinction matters when reading it. You cannot expect critical memoir to devote space proportionally to every movement in world cinema. You can ask that its enthusiasms be grounded in observations, and that its hypotheses not take the place of facts. The book’s interest lies in this combination: the author describes how a film affected him, then tries to explain why it deserves continued discussion.

The reading is more rewarding when you keep two points in time in view. There is the child or young person encountering a screening, and there is the adult filmmaker returning to that memory with a different kind of professional experience. Each can shed light on the other, but they are not equivalent. A remembered reaction does not represent every audience; a later explanation does not reproduce the initial perception intact.

Actors, genres and films that might have existed

In his November 2022 review, David Bordwell noted the importance the book places on actors, characters, dialogue and audience response. He also highlighted Tarantino’s contrast between filmmakers who challenge genres and those who seek to renew them out of affection. This observation helps explain why his criticism may linger on an actor’s presence or a line of dialogue rather than offer a technical description of the camera.

The actor is not simply presented as a component carrying out the director’s plan. They bring expectations with them: ways of moving, previous roles and an image the audience recognises. Thinking about Steve McQueen in Bullitt invites us to ask how much the film depends on watching him act without explaining everything he is thinking. That question puts performance at the centre of the experience, rather than treating it as an embellishment of the plot.

The book’s title is most explicitly realised in the chapter that imagines Taxi Driver directed by Brian De Palma rather than Martin Scorsese. The alternative is a critical exercise, not an announcement that this version exists. Its value lies in making us specify what is distinctive about the actual film: what would change in its tone, its relationship with the protagonist or its staging if it were shaped by a different sensibility?

The method can be applied to an imagined cast or a screenplay decision, but it needs to remain hypothetical. A possibility is intriguing when it reveals something that had previously gone unnoticed. It loses force if it ends up replacing analysis with a desire for a film that does not exist. Reading the book attentively means enjoying the author’s imagination without turning his alternatives into production facts.

The chapters on works less prominent in the usual lists also broaden the reader’s map. The contents place The Outfit and Paradise Alley alongside much more frequently cited titles. This company makes it possible to discuss genre cinema without expecting all its achievements to take the form of a monumental work. A performance, a relationship between characters or a resolution can deserve attention that its general reputation has not granted it.

How to make the most of its enthusiasms and disagreements

The book is especially rewarding as a companion to film viewings. Reading a chapter after watching the film lets you test a claim against scenes still fresh in your memory. Reading beforehand can direct your attention, but may also reveal plot details. It is not a collection designed to systematically preserve every surprise for readers unfamiliar with the films discussed.

Nor does its personal tone require agreement. A forceful statement can be entertaining and still call for discussion. You may agree with the description of a technique while disagreeing with the value Tarantino assigns to it. This possibility distinguishes criticism from a simple instruction to watch: what matters is what it helps you see, even when it does not entirely convince you.

Its relationship with Pauline Kael as a critical touchstone helps put that voice in context, while his film reviews show the practice in writing of a different format. Cinema Speculation offers more room to connect memories, films and arguments. Its greatest value is not in turning Tarantino’s taste into a compulsory canon, but in opening a specific conversation about images that continue to produce pleasure, unease and disagreement.

Return to Tarantino’s books, criticism and film projects.

View all articles in Tarantino as a critic: books, podcasts and cinemas