Tarantino’s “perfect” films and the nuance of The Wild Bunch

The well-known selection came up during a televised conversation about Cinema Speculation. It includes horror, comedy, adventure and westerns, as well as an exception that Tarantino himself wanted to qualify.

A conversation in October 2022, not a universal vote

During his appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live on 27 October 2022, Tarantino talked about films he considered perfect. The question began with Tobe Hooper’s The Texas Chain Saw Massacre. Jaws, The Exorcist, Annie Hall, Young Frankenstein, Back to the Future and The Wild Bunch also came up in the conversation. These are titles mentioned in that context, not the winners of a survey held to determine a definitive canon.

The word perfect referred to the strength of a work, even for someone whose tastes might differ. That idea is not the same as promising there are no continuity errors whatsoever, or declaring that everyone should enjoy the same films. Tarantino was offering a critical judgement, with the emphasis and approximations typical of an interview on an entertainment show.

There are two nuances that abbreviated lists often lose. Young Frankenstein appears as a choice he could understand someone putting forward. The Wild Bunch comes with an explicit reservation: its imperfections are part of its greatness. Turning the conversation into seven identical certificates of flawlessness erases precisely the differences the director introduced in his response.

Nor was there a ranking from first to seventh. The order of a conversation reflects associations and questions, not necessarily a hierarchy. For anyone looking for films to watch, the selection is a useful tour through very different kinds of cinematic effectiveness. Its variety is more interesting than an invented score between them.

Horror, comedy and adventure achieve different effects

The Texas Chain Saw Massacre creates an experience of disorientation and physical threat. Its power does not depend on explaining every aspect of the setting it presents. The spaces, sounds and repetition of certain images make viewers sense a hostile world. Analysing how effectively it does this does not require agreeing with every interpretation of the film or attributing every formal observation to Tarantino.

The Exorcist follows a different progression. The disturbance invades a domestic setting and forces different characters to seek an explanation. Its combination of family drama and horror gives the extraordinary concrete emotional consequences. The threat is not reduced to a display of effects: it affects relationships and beliefs that the film has given us time to recognise.

Tarantino’s defence of Jaws reflects his admiration for popular cinema capable of creating a shared experience. Spielberg’s film combines a clear threat with disagreements between people who have to respond to it. The anticipation, incomplete information and the protagonists’ interactions sustain interest alongside the attacks.

Annie Hall and Young Frankenstein show that the conversation is not limited to violent stories. The first makes sentimental memory and the way it is told part of the comedy. The second draws on a visual and narrative tradition that it can parody while still creating its own characters and situations. Humour requires precision, even when its effects are unlike those of suspense. In Annie Hall, changing the order of a memory alters our relationship with a romantic experience: the narrator returns to it, disputes it and presents it from a distance that is also part of the joke.

Back to the Future and the exception of The Wild Bunch

Back to the Future offers an example of clear relationships between setup and consequence. Objects, lines and situations take on new meanings when the point in time changes. Viewers can recognise connections without the adventure losing momentum. Its narrative mechanism is especially visible because the film invites us to remember details that seemed minor and see how they return transformed.

That precision does not mean the experience is all about solving a puzzle. Marty’s situation affects his family relationships and the way he sees his parents. Time travel allows the film to combine urgency, comedy and intimacy. The construction works because the rules and emotions are connected, not because an abstract explanation of time travel takes centre stage in every scene.

Released in 1969 and directed by Sam Peckinpah, The Wild Bunch introduces a different idea of excellence. A work can contain rough edges, excesses or imbalances and retain a force that is difficult to reduce to a list of flaws. Tarantino’s qualification is valuable precisely because it allows for that possibility in a conversation about perfection. The term no longer means uniform polish.

These films make it possible to compare experiences rather than impose a single taste. Some concentrate their energy on threat, others on verbal dexterity, memory, adventure or the decline of a group. The 2022 selection records a specific contribution from Tarantino and offers ways into these different approaches to filmmaking. Keeping the nuances of the conversation lets us enjoy it without turning an off-the-cuff response into a closed doctrine.

Back to films recommended by Tarantino.

View all articles in Films recommended by Tarantino: sources and selections