Immediate enthusiasm and later reconsideration offer two distinct ways of approaching science fiction as a viewer.
Two specific opinions about films from 1979
In Five Things, the conversation with Lynn Hirschberg published by W in April 2020, Quentin Tarantino recalled Alien as an event that had retained its power. About Star Trek: The Motion Picture, he described a change: several disappointments gave way to greater appreciation when he rewatched it with his wife. These are different assessments, not two identical endorsements.
The second reference is to the 1979 film directed by Robert Wise. It should not be confused with J. J. Abrams’s 2009 feature or with the entire franchise. An opinion about one instalment cannot automatically tell us a viewer’s preferences about all the others. Likewise, praise for Alien alone does not establish a particular position on any other work by Ridley Scott.
These two films are enough to put together a double feature with clear contrasts. Both take human beings into an experience beyond their understanding, but they handle anticipation, technology and the encounter with the unknown in very different ways. Tarantino’s comment serves as a starting point; the comparison that follows considers what the films show, without presenting it as his explanation for each formal choice.
Alien: a workplace turned into a threat
The ship in Alien has a recognizable material reality before the main danger appears. Its occupants work, argue about conditions and share a space that doesn’t seem designed solely for heroic adventure. This everyday dimension makes it easy to relate to them: the setting may be extraordinary, but tensions between co-workers and differences in responsibility feel familiar.
The arrival of a threat changes how we see that same place. A corridor is no longer just a passage; it becomes a possible site of attack. An opening or a dark surface takes on significance because we don’t know what it might conceal. The film uses partial information to make a familiar space seem progressively less controllable.
Technology doesn’t guarantee safety, either. Having information systems doesn’t always mean getting an adequate answer or understanding the interests behind a mission. That gap between technical capability and trust creates a different kind of unease from a physical pursuit. The characters may depend on instruments whose logic doesn’t fully align with their need to survive.
The combination of science fiction and horror works because both elements bear on the same problem. The unknown organism threatens bodies, while the conditions of the expedition determine what options are available for confronting it. This isn’t simply a matter of placing a monster in an indifferent futuristic setting. Isolation, access rules and authority relationships give the danger a specific shape.
As you watch, pay attention to how long simple actions take. Walking, waiting for a response or checking a place can take longer than we’d like. That delay makes us share the characters’ uncertainty. The film builds tension both through what it shows and through the interval when we still don’t know what we’re going to see.
Star Trek: The Motion Picture and the time of exploration
Robert Wise’s film proposes a different pace. Moving towards an unknown presence and contemplating its scale are central parts of the spectacle. For a viewer expecting a rapid succession of incidents, that duration can seem like an obstacle. If exploration is accepted as an experience in itself, the time spent observing takes on a different purpose.
The Enterprise is also a workplace, but the staging creates a different relationship with its procedures. The crew’s coordination and interpretation of signals make it possible to turn the incomprehensible into a shared problem. The story gives weight to the question of communication: understanding what lies before you may be more decisive than responding immediately with force.
The encounter also brings technology face to face with questions of identity and desire. An intelligence may have extraordinary abilities and yet not understand the meaning of its own search. This combination shifts the tension away from mere material superiority and towards the limits of experience. Knowing a great deal and understanding what is missing are not necessarily the same thing.
Comparing it with Alien shows how the value of waiting changes. In one film, a prolonged journey can heighten the fear of an attack. In the other, a prolonged approach can make us feel the scale of something we still don’t know how to interpret. Both require us to reckon with the unknown, but one favours physical vulnerability while the other allows more room for wonder and investigation.
The change of opinion Tarantino described about Star Trek: The Motion Picture also invites us to distinguish a film from the expectations we bring to it. Revisiting a work doesn’t mean you have to end up admiring it, though it can help you recognize the experience it offers more clearly. In this double feature, the contrast between the terror of confinement and the contemplation of an encounter offers a more precise path than a generic list of titles supposedly approved by the director.
See the selection of Tarantino recommendations by genre.
View all articles in Films recommended by Tarantino, by genre
