Tarantino’s Star Trek and Mark L. Smith

The Star Trek project went as far as script development with Mark L. Smith. Comments from those involved offer a sense of the intended tone and some of the references, but they don’t reconstruct a complete film.

A Tarantino idea developed by another screenwriter

The Star Trek project associated with Quentin Tarantino became public in 2017 and moved forward with Mark L. Smith as screenwriter, based on an idea by the director. J. J. Abrams was involved in its development. The division of roles matters: referring to it as Tarantino’s script may work as journalistic shorthand, but it shouldn’t erase Smith’s work or turn every line attributed to the project into something personally written by the filmmaker.

The possibility was striking because it brought together a science-fiction franchise and a director whose work had focused on other genres. However, Star Trek had used a wide variety of storytelling approaches since its earliest seasons. Its voyages made it possible to encounter societies reminiscent of eras, political systems or conventions from Earth’s culture. That flexibility could allow for a personal take without necessarily abandoning the premise of exploration.

Public information described an adult-oriented approach, usually summed up by the term R-rated. That label conveyed an intended tone in terms of violence and language. It wasn’t an official rating given to a completed film: rating bodies assess a specific work. The project never resulted in a released feature film that received such a rating.

The fact that writing work took place does distinguish it from an idea mentioned just once in an interview. Smith spoke about his involvement and the conversations he had with Tarantino. Even so, having a script in development doesn’t mean all its elements were final, or that filming had begun.

The reference to A Piece of the Action

Reports about the project linked it to A Piece of the Action, an episode of the original series in which the crew encounters a society that has imitated the world of American gangsters. The reference offered a point of connection between the Star Trek universe and Tarantino’s interest in crime, group codes and the performance of roles.

The original episode uses this imitation to create humour and cultural conflict. Kirk and Spock have to understand rules based on an incomplete image of another society and adapt to them. Science fiction allows an Earth-based model to reappear in distorted form on another planet. This approach lends itself to a discussion of how fiction or a document can influence the behaviour of those who encounter it.

Linking the project to that episode doesn’t mean Smith wrote a scene-by-scene remake. A reference can serve as a starting point, a backdrop or a narrative device. Without access to an authorized, complete version of the script, it would be inappropriate to invent dialogue, villains, crew crossovers or an ending that the available comments don’t describe.

The appeal of the crossover lay in the possibility that the Enterprise officers would have to navigate a system of threats and negotiations familiar from crime films. That interpretation explains a potential affinity; it doesn’t establish how much of the story would have taken place there or how it would have been balanced with space exploration.

Smith’s account and the film that never happened

In a 2023 interview with Collider, Smith recalled the excitement of the work and spoke about the intense violence they had imagined. He also attributed Tarantino’s doubts to the possibility that Star Trek might become his last film. That explanation should be treated as the screenwriter’s account of their conversations, not as a comprehensive explanation of every business decision related to the project.

The number of feature films Tarantino has said he wants to direct adds particular pressure to any choice. A franchise project could interest him while also raising questions about how to bring his career to a close. His comments about his last film offer a way to follow that discussion, which shifts over time and provides no automatic formula for predicting his next work.

Smith’s enthusiastic comments about the film’s potential quality express a personal opinion. They can’t be verified as though they described a result seen by audiences. A script can excite its writers and still require decisions about directing, performance, editing and production that transform the final experience. The significance of those comments is that they show the confidence that existed during development.

The existence of a script developed by Smith makes it possible to speak of written development, but it doesn’t turn public descriptions into a definitive list of scenes, characters or casting decisions.

Tarantino’s Star Trek therefore remains a project with writing work and specific accounts from those involved, but no released film. Its story points to a possible meeting of space adventure and gangster cinema. Keeping the television reference, Smith’s authorship and the project’s unrealized status clear makes it possible to appreciate that possibility without presenting an imagined work as a lost instalment of the franchise.

Back to Tarantino’s cancelled projects.

View all articles in Tarantino’s Unmade Projects: Ideas, Scripts, and Decisions