Forty Lashes Less One: The Leonard Western That Interested Tarantino

Tarantino discussed adapting Forty Lashes Less One for television, but his statement described a four- or six-hour possibility. The novel and the audiovisual project should be treated as works with distinct statuses.

A prison novel set in the western genre

Forty Lashes Less One is a novel by Elmore Leonard, published in 1972. Its story is set in the territorial prison at Yuma and brings together Harold Jackson, a Black former soldier, and Raymond San Carlos, a Chiricahua Apache. Both men face hostility that combines confinement with racism, and move from enmity to an alliance they need in order to find a chance at freedom.

The official presentation of the work places the action in 1909, a relatively late period compared with the most familiar image of the western. This setting allows the genre to shift towards institutions, regulations and forms of control that coexist with frontier violence. The open landscape is there, but the protagonists begin confined to a space that limits every move.

The relationship between the two provides a strong dramatic core. Sharing a situation of exclusion does not mean immediately trusting someone else. Their alliance must overcome rivalries and recognize common interests. This transformation allows the story to examine cooperation as a practical decision, forged under pressure, rather than presenting it as an automatic bond.

The novel is a published work that can be read on its own. Tarantino’s later interest adds a story of a possible adaptation, but it does not make the novel his screenplay or allow its characters to be attributed to him. Leonard is the author of that world and its conflicts. The distinction is especially important when an unrealized project becomes better known by the filmmaker’s name than by the book that came before it.

The 2015 statement: four or six hours

In December 2015, while promoting The Hateful Eight, Tarantino told Première that he owned the rights to Forty Lashes Less One and had long wanted to adapt it. He suggested it could become his third western and said he envisioned it for television as a four- or six-hour miniseries. The figure of three hours does not correspond to that statement.

The wording was conditional. The director was speaking about an intention and a format he was considering, without announcing a network, a finalized cast or the start of filming. There is a substantial difference between owning rights and producing an adaptation: the rights make it possible to develop the material, but do not guarantee that all the steps needed to film it will be completed.

The longer format could have offered time to develop the relationship between the prisoners and the various forces that organize the institution. That possibility makes sense for a story in which living together and the transformation of an alliance matter as much as the ultimate goal. However, this interpretation does not show how Tarantino would have arranged the episodes or which scenes he would have added or removed.

The interview also placed the project within a way of working in which the director imagines sequels and alternate paths before choosing something else. This context helps us understand the announcement in light of its actual level of commitment. An idea expressed with enthusiasm can be significant and still remain unproduced for years.

The affinity with Leonard and the project’s limits

The influence of Elmore Leonard on Tarantino is based on more than this adaptation. The attention to how characters speak, the blend of humour and menace, and the practical interests that drive a conversation offer recognizable affinities. In a prison story, these qualities can take on particular force because words make it possible to negotiate in a space where almost everything is restricted.

Jackson and San Carlos also introduce a conflict between the labels imposed on them by the institution and the abilities they develop in response. Confinement can turn them into categories before they are heard as individuals. Their relationship allows the story to explore an identity shaped through action and cooperation. This dimension helps explain why the material could interest a director attentive to underestimated characters.

Similarities to Django or The Hateful Eight do not establish that those films are covert adaptations of the novel. A thematic affinity must be distinguished from a production relationship or a direct transfer of scenes. The announced project was an adaptation of the book; comparisons with released works help analyse shared interests, not invent a textual lineage.

The television format would have required a specific organization of time: dividing a novel into instalments means deciding on breaks, pacing and points of view—decisions not detailed in the statement of intent.

Forty Lashes Less One remains an available novel and a discussed adaptation with no confirmed production. The reliable information identifies Leonard, the premise involving the two prisoners and the television proposal made in 2015. Keeping these elements separate preserves the project’s interest and avoids presenting as an existing miniseries what Tarantino described as a possibility he was considering.

Return to Tarantino’s cancelled projects.

View all articles in Tarantino’s Unmade Projects: Ideas, Scripts, and Decisions