The Once Upon a Time in Hollywood novel: another way to get to know Rick and Cliff

Tarantino’s novel returns to the world of his film, but offers a different experience. This comparison contains spoilers and distinguishes what the book tells us from what the feature film leaves open.

Reference edition and scope of the comparison

Once Upon a Time in Hollywood was published in 2021, two years after the film’s release. The Spanish edition used as a reference for this comparison is the Reservoir Books edition, ISBN 9788418052460. The publisher’s catalogue entry and the authorised opening excerpt have been consulted, along with the passage “Misfortune”, shared courtesy of the publisher. This provides a basis for examining specific differences without presenting consultation of excerpts as a complete reading of every edition.

The book is a work of narrative fiction. It is not the printed shooting script, a transcript of the dialogue or an autobiographical essay by the director. This distinction changes what readers can expect: a novel can enter characters’ thoughts, summarise extended periods and reorganise information without reproducing every shot. Its relationship with the film is close, but each work decides, through its own means, what the audience knows and when they know it.

Rick Dalton and Cliff Booth remain set in a Hollywood where fictional characters and historical figures coexist. This blend was already present on screen and calls for the same care on the page. A fictional conversation may mention real filmmakers without thereby becoming an account of them. A real name provides cultural recognition; the situation around it remains part of a literary construction.

The book’s later publication does not mean it should be treated as a definitive correction of the feature film. A work can add information while retaining deliberate differences in approach. When analysing a scene, viewers should distinguish between what appears in it and what they know from another version. This separation is especially important when a cinematic mystery accounts for a considerable part of a character’s appeal.

The prose changes our distance from the characters

The opening excerpt places Rick and Marvin Schwarz’s meeting in an office, while the film presents their conversation at Musso & Frank. The written narrative includes thoughts that are not spoken during the exchange. This access reveals a gap between the speakers’ outward politeness and their private assessments of one another. The dialogue retains its energy, but the prose can interrupt it to show something a camera would have to suggest in another way.

In the film, a pause or a look from Leonardo DiCaprio and Al Pacino can allow for several interpretations at once. The text can choose to name a specific mental reaction. Neither approach is automatically superior: they create different relationships with uncertainty. When the narrator offers an assessment, the reader has a precision that does not depend solely on interpreting a face, though they must also consider whose judgement it really is.

The case of Cliff Booth makes this difference particularly clear. The passage “Misfortune” states that he caused Billie’s death and describes his attempts to justify himself. The feature film keeps the shooting outside what is shown and leaves the interpretation of the boat scene open. The novel removes that uncertainty in its own version, but does not retroactively add a shot that was never in the film. A comparison with the mystery surrounding Cliff’s wife must keep both levels distinct.

It is also worth distinguishing between the narrative voice, a character’s perspective and the author’s opinion. A cruel justification can reveal how someone tries to defend themselves to themselves. Reproducing that reasoning within a work of fiction does not, in itself, amount to endorsing it as a moral principle. Analysis needs to observe the distance between what someone does and the words they use to minimise their responsibility, without automatically attributing every line to a personal statement by Tarantino.

A literary expansion is not a collection of deleted scenes

The novel allows more room for background and relationships, but not everything narrated in it needs to have been filmed. A new text can develop a possibility that never became a shooting scene. For this reason, the book’s expansions should be distinguished from audiovisual material preserved as extras. They are evidence of different processes: one shows what the novelist chose to tell; the other, what actors performed in front of a camera.

This distinction is useful when comparing Manson’s presence. His role in a novel can be expanded through narration or perspective, while the film’s deleted scenes allow us to observe specific performances by Damon Herriman. Bringing both materials together as if they formed a single extended version would create something that does not exist. Continuity between characters does not erase the difference between a published page and a filmed sequence.

The friendship between Rick and Cliff also offers a different experience in each medium. On screen, much of their familiarity comes from sharing time: driving, sitting together or remaining silent. Reading can provide background without reproducing that visual companionship exactly. Learning biographical information and spending time with two bodies in a shot are different ways of getting to know a relationship; they can complement one another without replacing one another.

Reading the novel after watching the film makes it possible to recognise these choices; reading it first can lead to a different distribution of expectations. In either case, it is worth preserving the autonomy of the film’s ending and its silences. The book offers another route into the same world, with a voice able to make explicit what the image holds back. The comparison is more fruitful when it attends to these differences in what is known, rather than reducing literature to a list of details missing from the screen.

More context in the Once Upon a Time in Hollywood guide.

View all articles in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood: characters, city and cinema