Tarantino and Kubrick: admiration, distance and specific films

The critical relationship between Tarantino and Kubrick cannot be reduced to a label of absolute admiration or total rejection.

The Killing disproves any blanket rejection

Quentin Tarantino has expressed reservations about Stanley Kubrick, but has also offered unequivocal praise for some of his films. In a 1992 interview with Paul Zimmerman for Orbit, while comparing The Killing with The Asphalt Jungle, he stated his preference for Kubrick’s film. That judgement predates many of the controversies that would later surround his opinions on cinema. Admiration for a specific work was already part of the conversation when he was introducing Reservoir Dogs.

The Killing, released in 1956 and known in Spain as Perfect Heist, helps explain that affinity without suggesting that both directors share an entire aesthetic. The story distributes information among several participants in a robbery, then revisits moments whose meaning changes as another perspective comes to light. Its precision lies not only in the characters’ plan: it also lies in the relationship the film establishes between what happens and the order in which the audience comes to understand it.

The device retains a decisive human dimension. The group’s members may agree on a procedure, but they cannot control all their desires, conversations and dependencies. A private weakness has collective consequences. The viewer appreciates the intelligence of the organisation while watching the conditions that threaten to undo it. This coexistence of calculation and fragility offers a point of contact with other crime stories, without needing to turn every similarity into a copy.

A Clockwork Orange: enthusiasm for some images, objections to the whole

In the profile of Tarantino published by The New Yorker in October 2003, we find both his distance from Kubrick’s cinema and his enthusiasm for the first twenty minutes of A Clockwork Orange. This combination contradicts the idea that he simply rejected the film. He can admire the power of an opening while questioning the stance he perceives in the film as a whole; these are judgements about different aspects.

The opening of A Clockwork Orange presents a world in which violence takes the form of representation. The costumes, music and arrangement of bodies compel us to watch brutal acts as organised images. This organisation is unsettling because it creates a distance between the horror of what is happening and the appeal of its construction. The viewer is not presented with neutral behaviour: they are presented with a staging that makes them aware of how they are watching it.

The moral debate arises precisely there. A film can depict reprehensible violence while using techniques that create fascination. Asking whether this tension is a contradiction or a strategy is a legitimate critical question. There is no answer that can be deduced solely from sympathy or antipathy towards the director. We need to examine how each sequence works and what changes the story later makes to our relationship with the character.

Alex, played by Malcolm McDowell, does not invite comfortable identification. His energy and ability to address the viewer coexist with actions that make it impossible to consider him an innocent figure. Later, the treatment he receives shifts the issue towards freedom and punishment. The film’s interest lies in keeping these questions connected without making them equivalent: understanding the danger of institutional intervention does not erase the harm previously caused by the person subjected to it.

Emotional distance and critical taste

When a filmmaker says another filmmaker feels cold to them, that description speaks to their experience as a viewer. It does not prove that the film lacks emotion, nor does it require all viewers to react in the same way. In Kubrick’s work, controlled composition, repetition and certain changes of scale can create a sense of strangeness. For some viewers, that strangeness cools the connection; for others, it makes it more intense by preventing an immediate, familiar response.

Tarantino often constructs situations in which conversation and sustained behaviour make a character feel close before conflict erupts. Kubrick may demand another kind of attention, more focused on the relationship between individuals, spaces and systems. This comparison describes visible techniques, not an absolute incompatibility. Both have worked with humour, menace and contradictions between what characters say and what they do.

That is also why it is unwise to automatically attribute a rejection of 2001: A Space Odyssey to Tarantino on the basis of a general reservation about Kubrick. An opinion about a director does not, by itself, provide a review of every title. To find out what he thinks of a particular film, we need an identifiable statement about that film. Viral lists often erase this distinction and turn a partial comment into a verdict on an entire career.

The accounts from 1992 and 2003 offer a more precise picture: a preference for The Killing, admiration for the opening of A Clockwork Orange and distance from certain effects of Kubrick’s cinema. This mixture is characteristic of a sustained critical relationship. It makes it possible to discuss editing, screen presence and the responsibility of images without demanding that the judgement end in total endorsement. Disagreement is more interesting when it keeps the films that prompted it in view.

Explore the selection of filmmakers and actors admired by Tarantino.

View all articles in The filmmakers and performers Quentin Tarantino admires