The Inglorious Bastards directly connects the two filmmakers. Keoma offers a broader view of Castellari without inventing a review of it by Tarantino.
The tribute does not turn the films into a remake
Quentin Tarantino has acknowledged the connection between the title of Inglourious Basterds and The Inglorious Bastards, Enzo G. Castellari’s 1978 film, known as The Inglorious Bastards. During the Q&A at the Castro Theatre, which Michael Guillén reported on for ScreenAnarchy on 24 August 2009, Tarantino explained his fascination with that title and with the general idea of a group on a mission. He did not present his film as a retelling of Castellari’s plot.
That clarification avoids a persistent misconception. Two works can share an expression, a family of stories or an explicit admiration without standing in an original-and-remake relationship. A remake requires a more concrete narrative continuity. A tribute can work on a different level: acknowledging a tradition and prompting audiences to remember another film as they enter a new story.
The filmed conversation between Castellari and Tarantino included in the 2008 edition of The Inglorious Bastards is another record of this connection. Its existence allows us to talk about an exchange between cinephiles, but it does not justify filling in the dialogue with praise that has not been verified. The relationship is interesting enough when grounded in identifiable encounters and statements.
The Inglorious Bastards and the group adventure
Castellari’s film follows soldiers turned fugitives, with a mission that makes the boundary between criminality and heroism unstable. The group’s structure creates conflict before the ultimate objective comes into view. The characters do not begin with complete trust in one another or with the comfort of an institutional role. They have to work together while holding on to their differing interests, temperaments and ways of reacting.
That premise lends itself to action in which the initiative can change hands. One character finds a way out, another complicates the plan, and another brings a necessary skill to bear at just the right moment. The audience needs to recognise each member well enough to understand what changes when they step in. Characterisation can be swift and rely on clear gestures while still serving a narrative purpose.
The film uses war as a setting for adventure, with an energy that is at odds with a solemn historical reconstruction. Uniforms, weapons and vehicles provide visible rules, but the focus is on the group’s journey. This choice of tone is open to debate; what matters is recognising it. Expecting the film to work exactly like a docudrama would make it harder to appreciate the kind of experience it is trying to create.
The train, as both an objective and a moving machine, provides an especially fertile structure for action. It forces the characters to coordinate timing, positions and access. One task has to be coordinated with another, and movement leaves little opportunity to stop and reorganise everything. The excitement builds when the film lets us understand the plan and then shows which part has become uncertain. The geography of danger matters as much as the number of explosions.
Keoma and another side of Castellari
Keoma, released in 1976 and starring Franco Nero, offers a useful contrast. This western combines homecoming, exclusion and family conflict in a much bleaker atmosphere. The protagonist enters a place defined by domination and disease, and his intervention pits him against both a collective order and personal ties that complicate the idea of belonging.
The way memories and figures from the past are presented alters the continuity of the action. Memory can intrude as a presence sharing the emotional space of the present, rather than functioning solely as explanatory information. This approach makes the character’s return feel burdened by experiences that have not been left behind. The adventure is threaded through with an intimate history that the protagonist seems to carry in his body.
The music contributes to a tone that can feel hypnotic or excessive, depending on the viewer. It does not simply accompany the scenes discreetly: it makes itself heard as a voice that comments on or intensifies the characters’ fate. This presence helps distinguish Keoma from any uniform idea of the Italian western. The genre allows for significant differences in pace, seriousness and the relationship between words, images and song.
The comparison also brings out how long a gesture lasts: a pause can imbue Keoma’s face with a sense of fatality, while a delay during the train mission threatens coordination that needs to keep working. The pace shifts with the dramatic problem.
Comparing Keoma with The Inglorious Bastards lets us see Castellari beyond a single label. The first offers an experience of homecoming and fatality; the second builds the pleasure of a collective mission. This contrast does not claim that Tarantino wrote a specific review of Keoma when no such review is documented. His admiration and tribute to the title open the door to a filmmaker with a filmography of his own, whose appeal does not depend on reducing every film to a forerunner of something made later.
Explore our selection of filmmakers and actors admired by Tarantino.
View all articles in The filmmakers and performers Quentin Tarantino admires
