Tarantino and television series: enthusiasm, memory and the limits of the format

His relationship with television combines admiration and reservations. Reducing it to a rejection of all modern series obscures what he has actually said.

Yellowstone: a critique that begins with enthusiasm

On The Joe Rogan Experience on 10 December 2024, with Roger Avary, Tarantino spoke about his experience of Yellowstone. He praised the first season, Kevin Costner’s presence and the writing; he had kept watching the series and had also watched 1883. He then questioned how much those stories stayed with him. His comment did not come from a refusal to watch television.

That nuance changes the meaning of the discussion. Enjoying a series while watching it and feeling that it leaves a smaller imprint than a film are compatible judgements. They do not mean that he thought every season was bad or denied that television staging could have any cinematic qualities. The question he raised concerned the cumulative effect of the experience and how it is remembered afterwards.

In that conversation, he also singled out the first season of Homeland, while expressing reservations about extending series. This is a personal view about duration and dramatic payoff, not proof that all viewers remember stories in the same way. Memory also depends on where you are in life, how closely you pay attention and the relationship each person forms with the characters.

Television westerns and the appeal of the episode

When speaking with Kim Morgan for Sight & Sound in 2015, Tarantino linked The Hateful Eight with television westerns such as Bonanza and The Virginian, particularly the arrival of guest characters. That interest helps explain his appreciation for television that builds contained conflicts around visitors, suspicions and temporary changes in a familiar community.

A character who appears for one episode can introduce a threat without the audience knowing their whole story. The guest cast brings a recognisable presence, but the story must quickly establish what the character wants and how much of what they say can be believed. This economy favours scenes where a conversation changes the level of trust before any decisive action takes place.

A series’ continuity, in turn, provides stable ground. Viewers know certain characters and places, so even a small change can become significant. A visitor forces them to reconsider rules that seemed settled. Episodic television can create variety precisely by repeating a framework and changing the conflict that runs through it.

This possibility differs from a story that postpones resolving its main problem over many instalments. Neither form is necessarily superior. A self-contained episode can rush towards a solution; a long-running series can develop relationships with a richness that is difficult to achieve in two hours. The critical question is what a work gains from its duration and what costs it incurs by sustaining it.

The difference between continuity and culmination

A film usually asks viewers to understand its duration as a bounded whole. The scenes relate to an ending that reshapes what came before, even if it does not resolve every question. That concentration can create a vivid memory of a gesture or decision. The ending gives viewers a point from which to look back over the journey in their minds.

A series can work differently. Spending time with its characters, the gradual transformation of relationships and the wait between instalments all form part of the experience. Its value does not always lie in taking every element towards a single culmination. Sometimes what matters is inhabiting a narrative world over an extended period and noticing changes that a shorter structure would have to condense.

Tarantino’s critique invites us to consider when that continuity becomes mere postponement. A conflict may be sustained because it still offers new discoveries, or because the story needs to keep a reason for continuing. The difference can be seen in the consequences: if a decision transforms relationships, time adds something; if everything continually returns to the same point, viewers may feel that the promised progress is being delayed without an equivalent payoff.

It is also worth distinguishing visual quality from narrative form. A series can use elaborate cinematography, complex camera movements and precise sound design without being structured as a film. Sharing techniques does not erase the differences in duration, production and relationship with the audience. Likewise, a film does not become more cinematic simply because it has spectacular images.

The contrast between his affection for classic westerns and his reservations about certain current series need not be explained as an inconsistency. It can be understood as a preference for conflicts that reach a recognisable shape before being renewed. Viewers may share that preference or value precisely the continuity he questions. Either way, his comments are more useful when their examples and nuances are preserved.

The final question is what kind of satisfaction we seek: a story that reaches a culmination, a world to return to, or a combination of both. Tarantino has clearly expressed his preference for the cinematic experience, but he has also said that he can get caught up in series. That combination describes his position better than the idea of an indiscriminate rejection of contemporary television.

See the guide to Tarantino’s books, criticism and film projects.

View all articles in Tarantino as a critic: books, podcasts and cinemas