His relationship with television includes both admiration and reservations. Reducing it to a rejection of all modern series obscures what he has actually said.
Yellowstone: a critique that begins with enthusiasm
On The Joe Rogan Experience on December 10, 2024, alongside Roger Avary, Tarantino talked about his experience with Yellowstone. He praised the first season, Kevin Costner’s presence and the writing; he had kept watching the series and had also watched 1883. He then questioned how well those stories stayed in his memory. His comment did not stem from a refusal to watch television.
That nuance changes the meaning of the discussion. Enjoying a series while watching it and feeling that it leaves a smaller impression than a film are compatible views. They don’t allow us to claim that he thought every season was bad or that he denied television direction any cinematic qualities. The question he raised concerned the cumulative effect of the experience and how it was remembered afterwards.
In that conversation, he also singled out the first season of Homeland, while expressing reservations about series that carry on for too long. This is a personal opinion about duration and dramatic payoff, not proof that all viewers remember stories the same way. Memory also depends on where we are in life, how closely we pay attention and the relationship each person forms with the characters.
Television westerns and the appeal of the episode
Speaking with Kim Morgan for Sight & Sound in 2015, Tarantino connected The Hateful Eight with television westerns such as Bonanza and The Virginian, particularly the arrival of guest characters. This interest helps explain his appreciation for television that builds concentrated conflicts around visitors, suspicions and temporary shifts in a familiar community.
A character who appears for one episode can introduce a threat without the audience knowing their whole story. A guest performer brings a recognizable presence, but the story must quickly establish what they want and how much of what they say can be believed. This economy lends itself to scenes where a conversation changes the level of trust before a decisive action takes place.
A series’ continuity, in turn, provides stable ground. Viewers know certain characters and places, so even a small change can become significant. A visitor forces them to reconsider rules that had seemed settled. Episodic television can create variety precisely by repeating a framework and changing the conflict that runs through it.
This differs from a story that puts off resolving its central problem over many instalments. Neither form is necessarily better. A self-contained episode can hurry towards a solution; a long-running series can develop relationships with a richness that is difficult to achieve in two hours. The critical question is what a work gains from its duration and what costs it incurs by sustaining it.
The difference between continuity and culmination
A film usually asks viewers to interpret its duration as a defined whole. Its scenes connect to an ending that reshapes what we have seen, even if it doesn’t settle every question. This concentration can leave a powerful memory of a gesture or a decision. The ending provides a point from which to look back over the journey in our minds.
A series can work differently. Spending time with its characters, the gradual transformation of relationships and the wait between instalments all form part of the experience. Its value doesn’t always lie in directing every element towards a single culmination. Sometimes what matters is inhabiting a story world over an extended period and noticing changes that a shorter structure would have to compress.
Tarantino’s critique invites us to consider when continuity becomes mere postponement. A conflict may continue because it still yields discoveries, or because the story needs to preserve a reason to go on. The difference can be seen in the consequences: if a decision transforms relationships, time adds something; if everything keeps returning to the same point, viewers may feel that the promised progress is being delayed without an equivalent payoff.
It’s also worth distinguishing visual quality from narrative form. A series can use elaborate cinematography, complex camera movements and precise sound design without structuring the whole like a film. Sharing techniques doesn’t erase the differences in duration, production and relationship with the audience. Likewise, a film doesn’t become more cinematic simply by having spectacular images.
The contrast between his affection for classic westerns and his reservations about certain contemporary series need not be explained as an inconsistency. It can be understood as a preference for conflicts that reach a recognizable form before being renewed. Viewers may share that preference or value precisely the continuity he questions. In either case, his comments are more useful when we retain their examples and nuances.
The final question is what kind of satisfaction we’re looking for: a story that culminates, a world to return to or a combination of the two. Tarantino has clearly expressed his priority for the cinematic experience, but he has also said that he gets drawn into series. That combination describes his position better than the idea that he indiscriminately rejects contemporary television.
See the guide to Tarantino’s books, criticism and film projects.
View all articles in Tarantino as a Critic: Books, Podcasts and Theatres
