Tarantino’s heist-film tastes: The Killing and the plan that goes wrong

The selection starts by clearing up a title mix-up: The Killing should not appear twice in a list of recommendations.

Atraco perfecto and Casta de malditos are one film

The Killing, directed by Stanley Kubrick in 1956, is known in Spain as Atraco perfecto and in various Latin American markets as Casta de malditos. They are not two different thrillers. This distinction prevents a list of recommendations from being padded out and helps people find the right film, starring Sterling Hayden. The ICAA catalogue lists Atraco perfecto under its original English title.

Quentin Tarantino’s admiration for the film is backed by a specific record. In his 1992 interview with Paul Zimmerman for Orbit, he compared The Killing with The Asphalt Jungle, by John Huston, and said he preferred the former. The comparison places two heist stories in a real conversation. It is not a complete list of his favourites, nor does it mean the filmmaker praised both works in exactly the same way.

Kubrick’s film is a particularly useful choice for anyone coming to it via Reservoir Dogs. The connection should not be reduced to a search for copied scenes. What matters is seeing how a crime story can distribute its information, let the audience know part of the plan and hold other details back until later. The way the story is structured can create as much tension as the robbery itself.

The timing of the heist and the timing of the story

The Killingorganises a heist targeting the takings at a racecourse, with tasks that need to come together at the right time. The participants do not all do the same thing or have the same information. This division of labour brings clarity and fragility at once: the plan seems workable because each role is clearly defined, but a single failure can affect the whole operation. The audience learns to recognise that dependence before finding out whether it will hold.

The story revisits moments we have already seen from a different point of view. This repetition is not simply a matter of showing the same action twice. It can reveal what was happening while we were paying attention to something else, or change the meaning of a detail. The story’s timeline moves one way, while our understanding moves another. The film turns that difference into a tool for building suspense.

This approach requires the audience to be oriented. If we do not have a rough idea of where a scene fits, complexity can become confusion. When the orientation works, however, going back creates anticipation: we know the outcome and want to understand its cause, or we know two actions will have to intersect. Narrative precision depends on what is repeated, what is left out and what new information justifies each return.

The planning also characterises the criminals. The allocation of tasks reveals trust, hierarchy and need. The organiser may imagine a coherent operation, but has to carry it out with people whose lives continue beyond the plan. That difference stops the group from working like a perfect machine. The expected money enters conversations and relationships, where it takes on meanings the boss cannot control.

Private weakness within a collective operation

The scenes away from the racecourse are essential to understanding why the heist cannot be judged as a technical problem alone. Wanting to impress someone, domestic frustration or misplaced trust can bring dangerous information into circulation. The film shows that secrecy has a social life. Keeping a secret does not depend only on following an instruction: it depends on each participant’s ability to live with what they cannot tell anyone.

At this point, the comparison with The Asphalt Jungle, from 1950, is useful. Huston gives attention to the group and the needs that lead it towards crime. The plan brings different people together for a limited time without erasing their weaknesses. Watching both films makes it possible to compare the weight given to temporal structure, living together and the individual fate of those involved.

The appeal of heist films often comes from a contradiction: we want a mechanism to work, yet we know a story needs to put it in danger. The characters’ skill can be impressive even when their aims are criminal. The story uses that engagement to make a small mistake seem enormous. An everyday detail can destroy an operation that appeared to have anticipated every major obstacle.

The racecourse also provides a public activity that continues while the crime is being prepared. The routines of the event give the thieves schedules and opportunities, but also bring in people who have nothing to do with the plan. The heist depends on taking advantage of an organisation that none of them fully controls.

That is why The Killingis worth watching without reducing it to a manual for writing non-linear screenplays. Its use of time matters because it is bound up with people who want things, make mistakes and trust one another to different degrees. Tarantino’s praise gives us a reason to take a look; the film then offers its own reasons to stay in our memory. And recognising its different titles stops a good recommendation from becoming, through a simple mix-up, two imaginary entries in the same catalogue.

Browse the selection of Tarantino recommendations by genre.

View all articles in The films Tarantino recommends, by genre