Quick-witted dialogue, difficult relationships and theatrical misunderstandings offer a way into the director’s comic tastes.
Three recommendations with different shades
In August 2009, Tarantino included His Girl Friday among his favourites and praised Anything Else in his interview with Ella Taylor for The Village Voice. In Five Things, published by W in 2020, he recalled how much La Cage aux Folles amused him, even when he rewatched it at home. These three comments let us talk about enthusiasm for comedy without making up a list of films to switch off to.
The label feel-good should be used with care. A film can be very funny and still contain manipulative relationships, anxiety or social conflict. Tarantino enjoying it does not mean he recommended it as an emotional remedy, or that every viewer will come away feeling the same way. It is more useful to identify the kind of humour that shapes each title.
All three works feature adults whose relationships require them to negotiate conflicting desires. One moves between marriage and journalism; another observes emotional insecurities; the third turns a family gathering into an unstable performance. This is different from the territory of teen comedies, where the peer group and the discovery of an identity often play a different role.
His Girl Friday: falling in love in the middle of an argument
Howard Hawks’s 1940 film, known in Spain as Luna nueva, brings Cary Grant and Rosalind Russell together in a relationship inseparable from work. Hildy Johnson is trying to take a different direction, while Walter Burns uses his powers of persuasion to keep her close. Their rapport is clear in how quickly they understand each other, even when their aims clash.
Dialogue functions as action. Talking can delay a decision, deflect a question, change an alliance or stop another character imposing their version of events. The pace is not an embellishment added to a story that could be told just as well in silence. It is part of how these people compete, and part of the pleasure of watching performers who can respond without losing the scene’s momentum.
The film also keeps the cost of that energy in view. Professional skill and personal charm do not make all of Walter’s manoeuvres acceptable. Viewers can enjoy his ingenuity while recognising his desire for control. This ambivalence stops the relationship from becoming a simple celebration of two people destined to be together.
For a first viewing, it is useful to follow Hildy’s journey: when a decision seems truly hers, when she is responding to pressure, and when an interest in a news story reshuffles her priorities. The romance is expressed through a mutual understanding that can be both exhilarating and dangerous. The film finds comedy in that closeness without entirely separating desire from competition.
Anything Else and La Cage aux Folles: insecurity and performance
Anything Else, directed by Woody Allen in 2003, uses a romantic relationship to explore the distance between what a person understands and what they manage to do. The protagonist can receive advice and recognise problems, yet remain caught in his own hesitation. The comedy comes from this mismatch between analysing a situation and being able to act within it.
Its tone does not require every character to be likeable. Frustration and dependence create awkward situations, and the humour can arise precisely from prolonging behaviour that viewers might want to interrupt. Anyone looking for a reassuring romantic comedy should bear that roughness in mind. A filmmaker’s enthusiasm does not erase the differences between their taste and the expectations of someone choosing a film for the evening.
The attention to dialogue offers a link with Hawks, although the rhythm and effects are different. In His Girl Friday, a quick response often demonstrates competence. In Anything Else, talking can reveal an inability to resolve what is being discussed. Conversation does not always bring people closer to a decision: it can also become a way of putting it off.
La Cage aux Folles, directed by Édouard Molinaro in 1978, shifts the focus to the couple, family and the obligation to keep up appearances. Preparing for a meeting turns everyday behaviour into a watched performance. The characters try to control gestures, objects and accounts of their lives so they fit what they imagine the visitors will accept.
The comedy depends on the fact that this performance can never be completely controlled. The more rigid the role someone has to play, the more visible any mismatch becomes. The audience knows the effort hidden behind a phrase or a movement and anticipates the moment when the artifice will stop holding together. The house becomes the stage for a play its own inhabitants struggle to perform.
Comparing the three titles makes it possible to choose by experience: speed and verbal skill in Hawks, emotional awkwardness in Allen, and family misunderstandings and theatricality in Molinaro. None of these choices requires treating the films as models for relationships or sharing all their comic devices. Tarantino’s comments support the interest of this viewing journey; watching each work lets you decide what kind of humour feels stimulating, irritating or surprisingly familiar.
Explore the selection of Tarantino recommendations by genre.
View all articles in The films Tarantino recommends, by genre
