A revenge film can promise release and end up leaving a void. Tarantino’s documented selections include stories that take very different approaches to turning harm into action.
Rolling Thunder: a choice with a date attached
Rolling Thunder, directed by John Flynn in 1977, was among the films Quentin Tarantino selected for the 2012 Sight and Sound poll. That choice lets us recommend it with a precise attribution: it was among his selections for that poll. It does not prove that it always ranks first among his favourite revenge films, nor does it justify attributing any interpretation of its scenes to him.
The film follows Charles Rane, a veteran who returns from Vietnam to find a society ready to celebrate his homecoming, but largely unable to understand him. William Devane portrays a character whose restraint makes it difficult to distinguish discipline from emotional detachment and suffering. Before the story turns into a pursuit, the homecoming is already a crisis. The violence that follows does not create a wounded man from nothing: it encounters an earlier experience of captivity and loss.
What makes this construction interesting is that revenge does not retrospectively resolve everything that came before. The protagonist can identify those responsible for a specific attack, but that does not turn the domestic world into the place he hoped to reclaim. Seen from this angle, the film is harsher than a simple fantasy of compensation. Its forward momentum offers recognisable goals and actions, while remaining guarded about what those actions can repair.
Tommy Lee Jones plays Johnny Vohden, another veteran whose relationship with Rane adds a dry form of camaraderie. Their cooperation needs no lengthy speeches to be understood. Familiarity with danger takes the place of some ordinary communication. This economy of words lets us observe something especially valuable in the genre: characters who act together without their agreement amounting to emotional recovery or a clearly imaginable future life.
Three revenge films brought together by the programmer
Another verifiable recommendation appears in the March 2011 programme at the New Beverly, curated by Tarantino. On the 8th, it brought together The No Mercy Man, Johnny Firecloud and Summertime Killer in a revenge-themed triple bill. This selection is more concrete than a list circulated without a source: it brings together titles, a date and a screening context. Its value lies in showing which films he wanted to put in conversation for an audience.
Johnny Firecloud, directed by William Allen Castleman, sets its conflict amid the racist violence suffered by an Indigenous veteran when he returns to his community. If you choose to watch it, it is worth paying attention to the difference between portraying an environment’s brutality and making that brutality an automatic justification for every element of the spectacle. The film builds up a deliberately unpleasant accumulation of assaults before giving the protagonist the capacity to respond.
This mechanism makes it possible to compare two scales of violence: personal harm and the collective permissiveness that makes it possible. The enemy is not simply an isolated opponent. Power relationships within the community determine who can protect themselves and who gets heard. The film belongs to exploitation cinema, with its excesses and questionable choices, but its inclusion in a themed screening does not mean it should be reduced to the amount of punishment it delivers.
Summertime Killer, directed by Antonio Isasi-Isasmendi, takes a different approach: revenge as a project that stretches from a childhood experience into adult action. The passage of time brings preparation, identity and a distance between memory and present-day goals. The idea of an avenger working through a list may feel familiar to Tarantino’s audience, though that resemblance is not enough to claim that every decision in his screenplays derives from this film.
The No Mercy Man, directed by Daniel Vance, adds another veteran and another conflict with the violence of the surrounding world. In a triple bill, the repetition of certain motifs is no longer a flaw to be concealed: it lets us see how the tone, protagonist and type of aggression change. The programming documents that opportunity for comparison. It does not declare that the three films have identical merits or provide the same satisfaction.
What not to mistake for a recommendation
Thriller: A Cruel Picture and Lady Snowblood often enter these discussions because of their relationship to Kill Bill. A visual influence, reused music and a favourable review are different kinds of evidence. A character’s patch or a similar trajectory cannot, on its own, establish a ranking of preferences. That is why the selection proposed here is based on a dated poll and a dated programme, rather than on a supposedly definitive list.
It is also worth distinguishing revenge from vigilantism. The avenger responds to an identifiable harm; the vigilante may take on a general mission to punish crime. The boundaries blur, but they change the relationship with the law and with victims. Stories about incarcerated women associated with his recommendations offer another combination of abuse, survival and rebellion, without every escape having to be classified as revenge.
Back to Tarantino recommendations by genre.
View all articles in The films Tarantino recommends, by genre
