The Killing, released in 1956 and known in Spain as The Perfect Heist, is a documented reference point for Reservoir Dogs. Andrzej Sekula recalled watching it with Quentin Tarantino while they were preparing the cinematography. The connection can be explored in the way a heist is organised and in the expectations created by a story that does not continually follow the order of events.
In Stanley Kubrick’s film, the plan requires tasks to be coordinated. The narrative can return to an interval to place another action within that mechanism. Tarantino also alters the chronology, but much of his back-and-forth is devoted to changing what we know about the men gathered after the robbery. The event around which the story revolves remains off-screen.
The difference affects the suspense. Understanding how a plan is supposed to work lets us fear that it will fail; hearing explanations of a failure forces us to decide whom to trust. Both approaches manage information, but they do not pose the same question to the viewer. This distinction helps identify the influence without reducing the two films to identical puzzles made up of out-of-order scenes.
A shared reference during preparation
The connection with Kubrick has concrete support in the crew’s work. In “From Rags to Reservoir Dogs”, by Stephen Pizzello, published in American Cinematographer in November 1992, Sekula recalled watching The Killing with Tarantino during their preparatory discussions. The account confirms they shared a reference, though it does not attribute every subsequent editing decision to that viewing.
Criterion’s film details identify Kubrick as the director and screenwriter of The Killing, Jim Thompson as responsible for the dialogue, and Lionel White’s novel Clean Break as the source material. Sterling Hayden plays Johnny Clay. The film revolves around a racetrack robbery, conceived as an operation that requires several actions to be coordinated.
That starting point turns time into a practical challenge. The precision of a heist depends on someone being where they need to be and acting when they are meant to. Telling the story of each task separately can make the plan understandable while also reminding us that each participant has control over only a limited part of it. The viewer has to connect actions that the characters cannot see all at once.
For comparison with Reservoir Dogs, the relationship between organisation and knowledge matters. The mere use of earlier scenes would not be enough to establish a meaningful connection: many stories interrupt the present to explain the past. Here, shifts in the placement of information affect how much trust we can put in a plan or in the people who say they carried it out.
The robbery we see and the robbery we don’t
In “The Killing: Kubrick’s Clockwork”, published by Criterion on 15 August 2011, Haden Guest analyses the fragmented chronology and the narrative voice that marks the hours and minutes. The story returns to events from the robbery and places different actions within a timetable. This voice provides a guide that lets us piece together the sequence of events as the film presents it in separate parts.
Repeating an interval creates a particular effect: what seemed to be an isolated action takes its place within a larger whole. The new scene can complete a section we have already covered without turning the earlier scene into a lie. The out-of-order presentation reveals dependencies. Each piece makes sense on its own, but its significance grows when we recognise what it enables or puts at risk.
Reservoir Dogsuses a different structure. Its main present-day storyline brings the survivors together in the warehouse, while the shifts into the past provide background on particular characters. The jewellery-store robbery remains absent. In his review of Tarantino’s debut for the BFI, updated in January 2022, Leigh Singer points out this difference from The Killing: the criminal operation Kubrick shows is elided in Tarantino’s film.
That is why we should not assume the flashbacks will necessarily piece together a complete version of the robbery. The film can clarify who a man is or how he joined the group, while leaving the action that triggers the meeting unseen. What the viewer gains is an ability to interpret behaviour. New information changes the meaning of an accusation, a silence or an expression of trust.
The difference becomes clear when we learn Mr Orange’s identity. That section does not complete a heist task by showing the same operation from another angle. It reshapes the viewer’s relationship with a character they have already seen wounded and protected. The earlier scene remains unchanged, but the gap between what White knows and what we know becomes decisive.
Verbal explanations also play different roles. The voice that sets out the timetable in The Killing guides our reconstruction of events. In the warehouse, an account comes from someone involved and can be challenged by someone else. A character’s confident description of an event does not automatically give them authority over the story.
From the mechanics of the plan to the dispute between colleagues
A heist plan turns personal differences into a coordination problem. While each member carries out their task, those differences can seem secondary. Failure changes their significance: one person’s decision affects those who depend on it. This principle allows us to compare the two films without treating them as stories concerned solely with the technical skill of a group of thieves.
Kubrick presents a visible structure whose precision can be tested against what happens. Tarantino focuses on men trying to explain a disaster whose consequences we only partly know. The question shifts from how the tasks fit together to which account of the failure will prevail. The discussion prolongs the danger because an interpretation can quickly become a decision against another member of the group.
Trust is therefore both practically useful and vulnerable. It makes it possible to act with others, but requires accepting information that cannot be verified all the time. When that acceptance disappears, every explanation has to be defended. Reservoir Dogs can sustain long exchanges after the main action because words determine who deserves help, who is suspect and who has the right to give orders.
The comparison with City on Fire places the relationship between infiltration and loyalty in another earlier work. The Killing offers a different point of comparison: the possibility of creating tension by deliberately presenting a criminal event incompletely. The reference becomes more precise when we consider its function in each film, rather than attributing Tarantino’s entire story to a single model.
One useful way to compare these structures is to distinguish when an event happens from when we learn about it. A scene set before the robbery can appear well into the film; its chronological position and its role in providing information do not coincide. Noting both helps avoid calling every return to the past a repetition or assuming that each fragment is a personal memory of the character who appears in it.
It is also worth distinguishing omission from uncertainty. A film can leave an action off-screen while making it clear that it happened. Another can show an action without us yet understanding its consequences. In Reservoir Dogs, the robbery’s absence does not make us doubt that it took place. In The Killing, seeing a task does not mean immediately understanding all its connections. These differences let us describe the editing with precise verbs: bring forward, delay, complete, revisit an interval or skip it. Each approach changes our access to the story in a different way.
View all articles in Reservoir Dogs: a heist told through its aftermath
