Fleischer’s rehabilitation calls for us to look at films that unsettle us because of what they show and how they involve the viewer.
An admiration that can be documented
Quentin Tarantino has expressed his admiration for Mandingo, directed by Richard Fleischer and released in 1975. At a press conference reported by AlloCiné on 9 August 2012, he named it among his favourite films by the director. The New Beverly’s official history also includes Fleischer among the filmmakers for whom Tarantino has curated seasons. These are two distinct forms of recognition: an explicit expression of appreciation and a programming activity.
That endorsement does not justify inventing a claim that Fleischer was the most underrated director in history, or a review of every film in his career. Appreciation can be supported by more precise facts. A season suggests that a body of work deserves time and attention; a statement about Mandingo identifies a specific preference. Both are more informative than a generic superlative with no date or context.
Fleischer worked in very different genres, which makes it especially useful to observe his directorial choices rather than look for an invariably identical style. His name may be associated with adventure, science fiction or crime stories. This variety does not rule out a recognisable narrative intelligence; it means we must look for it in how he organises space, distributes information and places the viewer before behaviour that is difficult to absorb.
Mandingo and the discomfort of representation
Mandingo presents a slave-owning world in which ownership is claimed over bodies, affections and reproduction. Personal relationships are tainted by a structure that gives some people power over others. The melodrama does not unfold outside that system: its jealousy, desires and conflicts depend on it. Intimacy is shaped by an inequality that makes it impossible to understand the characters’ decisions as though they all had the same freedom.
The film is unsettling because it combines condemnation with spectacle. Showing degradation can reveal the brutality of a social order, but the way it is shown can also create an exploitative experience. This tension cannot be resolved by appealing solely to the filmmaker’s intentions. We must ask how much space the story gives to those who suffer, from what vantage point their suffering is viewed, and what kind of response each sequence seeks to elicit.
In his TCM article published on 26 June 2018, Sean Axmaker recalls the film’s deeply divided reception and places it between exploitation melodrama and the representation of slavery. This critical history helps explain why its revival is not simply a matter of discovering an obscure title. It also means returning to a work whose impact had prompted very different judgements.
Tarantino’s defence is part of that discussion, but it does not exhaust it. A viewer may recognise its dramatic force while raising objections to its treatment of the characters. Another may feel that its rawness breaks with earlier ways of idealising the past. The useful approach is to specify which image or relationship supports each reading. The film should not be treated as an adequate historical reconstruction of slavery, or as documentary evidence for every act it depicts.
The Boston Strangler as a contrast in form
The Boston Strangler, released in 1968, offers a chance to observe another side of Fleischer. Its use of split screen distributes attention across actions, locations and investigative processes. The viewer must connect fragments rather than always receive a single image that organises all the information. The visual multiplication can suggest extensive activity without providing a complete understanding of the danger.
The effect is not simply a matter of showing several things at once. Each fragment occupies a position and duration that influence its importance. One image may be isolated while others seem to move forward; the whole may convey coordination or dispersal. The formal device becomes part of an experience of uncertainty, in which gathering facts does not yet amount to understanding the person who produced them.
Comparing it with Mandingo helps prevent Fleischer from being reduced to a single controversial subject. In one work, conflict is concentrated in relationships of domination within a social order; in the other, the investigation must build meaning from fragmentary information. This comparison is a critical proposition, not a review attributed to Tarantino of The Boston Strangler without verifiable testimony.
The distribution of information also changes our judgement: learning about a threat before a character does creates fear; discovering it afterwards forces us to reconsider the trust we had placed in a respectable appearance.
The strongest case for Fleischer begins with these differences. Watching an unsettling film does not require accepting all its effects or agreeing with the person recommending it. It requires giving it enough attention to distinguish what it shows, how it organises it and what questions it leaves open. Tarantino’s documented interest in Fleischer can begin that process; the subsequent assessment belongs to each viewer’s encounter with the works and the discussions they have prompted.
Explore the selection of filmmakers and actors admired by Tarantino.
View all articles in The filmmakers and performers Quentin Tarantino admires
