Paul Schrader according to Tarantino: screenplays, violence and responsibility

Admiring Rolling Thunder does not mean attributing every aspect of the film to its original screenwriter. This distinction shapes the discussion of Schrader.

The screenplay and the film are not the same thing

Quentin Tarantino’s critical relationship with Paul Schrader involves films directed by other people and differences between versions of a story. Taxi Driver, released in 1976, was written by Schrader and directed by Martin Scorsese. Rolling Thunder, released in 1977, was directed by John Flynn and credits Schrader and Heywood Gould as screenwriters. Starting with those credits helps avoid turning admiration for a cinematic result into exclusive attribution to one of its collaborators.

In Cinema Speculation, published in 2022, Tarantino examines both films and discusses narrative and moral choices. Momentary Cinema’s review of 22 October 2023 notes his interest in the differences between the protagonist in the screenplay for Rolling Thunder and the character played by William Devane. It also summarises his reading of Taxi Driver as a film about a racist man—a distinction that is not the same as declaring the work itself racist simply by identifying with its protagonist.

This is a question of authorship and reception. A screenplay proposes actions, dialogue and a structure for the story; the film adds bodies, voices, duration and images. These choices can intensify one aspect, shift another, or create a sense of sympathy that the writing did not resolve in the same way. To judge the result, we must observe this transformation, rather than imagine that the text was transferred to the screen intact.

Taxi Driver: intimacy without absolution

Travis Bickle has a hostile relationship with the city and organises his experience through a voice that tries to explain it. The viewer gains access to his thoughts, but that access does not guarantee that he is a reliable observer. The film allows us to notice contradictions between what he says, what he understands and what he does. Being close to someone’s consciousness does not oblige us to accept their diagnosis of the world.

Nor does the character’s loneliness automatically justify his actions. It can prompt compassion while also becoming a way of shutting himself into increasingly rigid interpretations. The dramatic interest lies in how this isolation relates to the desire to act. Travis seeks a role for himself and may confuse the intensity of his need with the legitimacy of a mission.

Robert De Niro’s performance complicates this relationship. There is awkwardness, vulnerability, uncomfortable humour and menace. None of these registers cancels out the others. One scene may bring us closer to the character, while the next makes us reconsider that closeness. This movement prevents us from reducing the experience to a simple choice between admiring him and rejecting him from the outset.

Violence then raises a question about the way we watch. A sequence can create excitement through its editing and shifts in intensity even as it depicts a terrifying act. Discussing this mix does not require us to pretend that every audience member will respond in the same way. The film shapes possible reactions, but each viewer may experience the relationship between tension, relief and revulsion differently.

Rolling Thunder and the difficulty of returning

In Rolling Thunder, a prisoner of war’s return home does not restore his former life. The public ceremony and private experience do not match. The character may be welcomed as a hero and still find himself unable to inhabit the relationships he left behind. This distance between recognition and belonging gives depth to a story that later takes the form of revenge.

William Devane brings a restraint that makes us read the smallest details. The absence of an open expression does not mean an absence of suffering. It may suggest an experience that the character does not know how—or cannot manage—to communicate in the terms expected by those around him. The film makes domestic normality seem strange, and makes certain relationships more comprehensible to him in a context of violence than in everyday life.

The presence of the companion played by Tommy Lee Jones introduces another form of recognition. People who share an experience may understand one another without needing lengthy explanations. This economy is dramatically powerful, but also unsettling: the ease with which they can act together again does not mean that their actions lead to recovery. A decision may seem clear precisely because it avoids much harder emotional problems.

A confession and an act of violence can offer contradictory versions of the same man. The screenplay gains complexity when it allows that contradiction to remain, rather than resolving it through a definitive psychological explanation.

The discussion of Schrader must preserve this complexity. It is not enough to celebrate a brutal screenplay or to use the word revenge as if that explained its meaning. What matters are the differences between versions, the viewer’s position and the way a film transforms violence into an emotional experience. The reading of Cinema Speculation helps place Tarantino’s judgements within a broader conversation, in which admiring a work can also mean debating key choices in its writing.

Explore the selection of filmmakers and actors admired by Tarantino.

View all articles in The filmmakers and performers Quentin Tarantino admires