Brian De Palma according to Tarantino: Blow Out and Carrie

Quentin Tarantino’s admiration for Brian De Palma has some concrete examples. Blow Out and Carrie offer two ways of turning a genre story into an emotional experience, using images that make the audience know, wait or understand too late.

Blow Out: hearing evidence and losing someone

In his 2011 essay on Blow Out, published by Criterion, Michael Sragow recalls Tarantino’s praise for John Travolta’s final close-up. He considered it one of cinema’s most heartbreaking moments. It’s a precise assessment of an image and its effect, enough to document his enthusiasm without adding an alleged ranking of all living directors.

Released in 1981, Blow Out follows a sound technician who records an accident and begins to suspect the recording contains evidence of a crime. The situation presents a distinctly cinematic problem: distinguishing what happened from what appears to have happened. The character listens, compares and reconstructs. His professional tools are also the means by which the film manages our attention.

The audience shares some of that investigation. An isolated sound changes meaning when connected to an image; a sequence that seemed complete reveals a gap. De Palma turns the manipulation of audiovisual material into dramatic action. The protagonist doesn’t need to run throughout the film for there to be danger: correctly ordering a few fragments can bring him closer to a truth others want to keep hidden.

The ending adds a wound to this mechanism. A scream from a tragedy ends up incorporated into cheap fiction. The work goes on, but for anyone who knows its origin, the sound can no longer be a neutral effect. The close-up Tarantino singled out lets us read the distance between the professional use of a recording and the painful memory it holds for one person.

Carrie and the distribution of the gaze

Carrie, from 1976, appears in Tarantino’s 2012 Sight and Sound poll selection. Its inclusion places the film among his stated preferences in that poll. There’s no need to attribute to him a detailed technical explanation the list doesn’t provide: the staging can be analysed directly and kept distinct from the documented choice.

The story gives Carrie’s vulnerability time to register before unleashing the horror spectacle. The school, home and dance create different forms of scrutiny and pressure. Being watched doesn’t mean feeling recognised: many of the people looking at her judge her, mock her or expect her to take the place they’ve decided for her. The audience knows how vulnerable she is and brings that knowledge to the celebration.

The dance sequence builds suspense by distributing information unevenly. The audience may perceive a danger the protagonist doesn’t know about. A kind gesture then takes on two meanings at once: it may bring Carrie relief, while unsettling those who anticipate her humiliation. This difference sustains the tension long before any display of power.

The dress, lighting and attention Carrie receives allow us, for a few moments, to imagine genuine acceptance. The threat matters precisely because the film gives that possibility weight. If the dance had been a caricature from the outset, with no promise of acceptance, its rupture would have had a different emotional effect.

When violence shatters the celebration, the visual choices change how we perceive the space. Fragmentation and multiple points of focus make it impossible to reduce what’s happening to a fight between two adversaries. The whole room is transformed. The formal excess responds to an emotional rupture the film has prepared through small, familiar situations.

Visual spectacle as emotional commitment

The two films show why it’s not enough to describe De Palma as a director of showy camera movements. In Blow Out, reconstructing images and sounds commits one person to another. In Carrie, knowing more than the protagonist makes the wait painful. The formal devices affect our relationship with the characters; they aren’t separate from them as mere decoration.

They also use the possibility of intervention in different ways. The technician believes that careful listening can correct the public version of an event. Carrie tries to find a place within a group that has the power to accept or destroy her. Both stories allow us to examine the distance between an illusion of control and real vulnerability, without claiming that Tarantino made exactly that comparison.

The praise for Travolta’s close-up is especially revealing because of its scale. A film full of technical operations ultimately concentrates its weight in a face. Emotion doesn’t require abandoning artifice: it emerges from everything the editing and sound have allowed us to know. An apparently simple image arrives laden with everything that came before.

Tarantino’s relationship with De Palma can be approached through two specific pieces of evidence and two viewing experiences. A poll documents his choice of Carrie; a Criterion essay preserves his comment on Blow Out. From there, the best way to approach that admiration is to look at how each film directs our attention and what feeling it leaves us with once the suspense mechanism has run its course.

See the selection of filmmakers and actors admired by Tarantino.

View all articles in The filmmakers and performers Quentin Tarantino admires