Poliziotteschi and Tarantino: Start with Calibre 9

The strongest recommendation leads to Fernando di Leo and a world of criminals who distrust one another. Italian crime cinema is about more than a rule-breaking inspector.

A recommendation from Venice

Quentin Tarantino’s enthusiasm for Milano calibro 9, released in 1972 and directed by Fernando di Leo, has a clearly identifiable public record. A Cinematografo article published during the 2004 Venice Film Festival recounts his interest in the retrospective of Italian genre cinema and his wish to keep discussing the film after seeing it again. Decades later, the 2024 San Sebastián Festival’s presentation also records his exceptionally positive assessment of the film.

That is a firmer basis than compiling ten violent Italian films and assuming they all receive the same endorsement. Venice lets us date a specific viewing event; the San Sebastián entry documents the lasting public record of that praise. Neither reference amounts to a comprehensive ranking of poliziotteschi films. So the sure choice to begin this journey is Calibre 9.

The name of the cycle needs some clarification. Poliziotteschi is commonly used for Italian crime films of the 1970s, but the genre includes films focused on police officers, criminals, and citizens who become vigilantes. Di Leo pays particular attention to the hierarchies of crime. Starting with his work does not mean you will always find a heroic inspector chasing an unmistakable villain.

What to look for in Calibre 9

The story centres on Ugo Piazza, played by Gastone Moschin, after his release from prison. His former associates suspect he knows more than he is letting on about some missing money. The premise creates a different kind of pressure from a conventional investigation: the protagonist has no neutral space in which to tell his side of the story. Each person he meets tries to size him up, intimidate him, or catch him in a contradiction.

Moschin’s restraint shapes much of the suspense. His body seems to bear questions the story is not yet ready to answer. The viewer shares the other characters’ struggle to read a face that gives little away, but does not necessarily share their interests. That distance makes identification uneasy: following Ugo is not the same as knowing who he is or being assured that he deserves our trust.

Mario Adorf brings an opposing energy. His verbal and physical outbursts make visible the violence of a system that can change its mood without changing its purpose. The confrontation between a reserved character and an expansive one sustains the tension even when nobody fires a shot. In this cinema, a conversation about money can work like a prolonged assault: what matters is who manages to impose their interpretation of what happened.

The urban setting is not interchangeable scenery, either. The movement between places of leisure, business interiors, and meeting places sketches a city shaped by competing interests. The question of the money leads to questions of loyalty and power. Crime is presented as an organized activity, with intermediaries and obligations, even as its participants resort to personal threats.

In my own critical reading, one of the film’s attractions lies in the imbalance between speed and waiting. There is action and violence, but the story needs a suspicion to remain unresolved. Watching it only for the chase scenes can mean missing its most persistent mechanism: forcing the characters to live with insufficient information. Violence punishes bodies; uncertainty shapes every decision they make.

Broaden the journey without inventing a Tarantino list

La mala ordina, also from 1972, and Il boss, from 1973, offer a way to continue exploring Di Leo’s crime films. Together with Milano calibro 9, they make up the collection known as the milieu trilogy. They are not three chapters of one adventure that must be watched to resolve an unfinished plot. Their connection lets us compare different ways of portraying criminal organizations, their enforcers, and their victims.

This expansion is a viewing suggestion based on the director’s work, not a transcription of a personal list by Tarantino. The distinction avoids attributing the content of two other films to a statement about one. It also helps reveal the range of the term crime film: in these stories, observing the criminal world from the inside can matter more than following someone trying to stop it.

If you’re choosing a film for a night in, Calibre 9 works well on its own. Afterwards, you might want to compare its tight-lipped protagonist with the power dynamics in the other films. You do not need to know all the later references to Di Leo in advance to understand it. Its characters, tension, and endings have a logic of their own, one that predates the admiration of American filmmakers.

Film buffs’ rediscovery of a movie is valuable when it leads from a famous name to a specific film. In this case, Tarantino’s enthusiasm opens the door; watching the film lets you decide whether you’re drawn to Moschin’s austerity, Adorf’s aggression, or the way a transaction becomes a threat. That decision belongs to the viewer and does not require adopting the recommender’s opinion as an obligation.

Back to Tarantino’s recommendations by genre.

View all articles in Films recommended by Tarantino, by genre