Chanbara and Lady Snowblood in Kill Bill Vol. 1

Chanbara is present in Kill Bill Vol. 1 in the importance given to the sword, the preparation for a confrontation, and the contrast between stillness and sudden violence. Lady Snowblood, directed by Toshiya Fujita in 1973 and starring Meiko Kaji, offers a specific reference point for understanding this connection. Its avenging swordswoman invites comparisons with Beatrix Kiddo and O-Ren Ishii, although each character occupies a different position in the story.

The comparison goes beyond the Japanese setting. It affects how an armed woman is presented, how a quest for revenge is structured, and how the colour of blood becomes part of the composition. There is also a musical connection: Kaji’s voice carries over from one film to the other. Tarantino brings these elements together in a contemporary world of professional assassins, international travel and settling scores. Examining what he preserves and what he changes clarifies both the presence of sword-fighting cinema and the particular importance of Lady Snowblood in Vol. 1.

Chanbara and the staging of the sword

Chanbara, also written as chambara, refers to Japanese films featuring sword fights. Jasper Sharp explains for the BFI that the name comes from the sound of blades clashing. Jidaigeki is period cinema; chanbara specifies its sword-fighting action strand. Kill Bill transposes elements of this tradition to characters living in the present: they carry swords, but also use telephones, aeroplanes and cars.

A weapon changes the way a space is occupied. An extended blade lengthens a character’s silhouette and draws attention to the distance between bodies. During a challenge, the opponents’ positions can communicate danger before either one attacks. Tarantino makes use of this possibility, alternating between a build-up of enemies and moments when a pair of figures facing each other is enough. The change in scale affects how long the viewer spends observing them.

The armed figures in Kill Bill pursue criminal and personal interests. Japanese samurai cinema allows for different positions on honour: Masaki Kobayashi’s Harakiri (1962) criticises the feudal order, as Sharp points out. This example helps us recognise the diversity of the tradition. In Tarantino’s film, skill with a sword does not confer moral superiority either: those who took part in the chapel attack also possess it.

This Japanese dimension is part of the dialogue between chanbara and Chinese martial arts in Tarantino’s cinema. It is worth distinguishing their contributions when watching a sequence: a Japanese setting, a choreography and a costume reference may come from different films. Vol. 1 brings these layers together without fully transferring the historical context of any one of them.

Lady Snowblood: a reference divided between two women

Marc Walkow offers a first-hand account in Film Comment in 2016: during a screening of Lady Snowblood at Sitges, he sat behind Tarantino and heard him explain the plot to a companion with familiarity and enthusiasm. The connection with Fujita is thus supported by evidence of personal familiarity, as well as similarities between the films.

The difference between their avengers lies in the origin of the mission. Yuki is born in prison and inherits a revenge mission that her mother wants carried out after her death. Beatrix pursues those who attacked her. This change shifts the emphasis of the decision: one protagonist has been raised to fulfil a mandate; the other resumes the action after surviving a betrayal. Both seek specific people, but their relationship to the harm they are trying to set right is different.

The visual resemblance shifts towards O-Ren. Her kimono and composed bearing bring her closer to Kaji’s swordswoman, while Beatrix takes the place of the one who moves from one adversary to the next. This arrangement allows the homage to be read without requiring the characters to be equivalent. The woman who visually recalls Yuki is, in Kill Bill, one of the protagonist’s targets. Recognition of the reference coexists with this reversal of roles.

Snow offers a precise example. In the opening minutes of Lady Snowblood, Yuki confronts some men in a snowy landscape, and blood marks the ground. Kill Bill brings together sword, snow and red again in the garden where O-Ren fights. The resemblance links compositions set at different points in their respective narratives. In one, it presents the protagonist’s ability to kill; in the other, it accompanies the culmination of a rivalry.

The song and the way the revenge story is told

In his essay for Criterion, Howard Hampton notes that Tarantino uses Shura no hana, known as The Flower of Carnage, performed by Meiko Kaji in Lady Snowblood. Its appearance at the end of the confrontation with O-Ren brings the voice of the actor who played Yuki into Kill Bill. The reference can be heard even when viewers do not recognise where it comes from.

The song also changes how we attend to the scene. After the fight, a sustained voice can fill the time previously dominated by the movements of bodies and the blows. When connected with Kaji, the ending takes on another association: the actor from the Japanese film that inspired it accompanies the farewell to a character who recovers some of her visual presence. Kaji’s voice can be heard as a reminder of the cinematic model within a scene featuring other protagonists.

Walkow also highlights the episodic storytelling in Lady Snowblood and Beatrix’s quest. Each encounter develops a particular obstacle and changes what we know about the past. Kill Bill emphasises this approach by showing the confrontation with Vernita before explaining the Japanese chapter. The viewer pieces together a journey that is already under way. Fujita intersperses images from the manga within the story. Vol. 1 uses animation for O-Ren’s past, changing its visual register when her story is introduced. Both films therefore allow for variations in how the episodes are represented.

Lady Snowblood came to the cinema after the manga written by Kazuo Koike and drawn by Kazuo Kamimura. Marc Walkow dates its original publication from February 1972 to March 1973. Norio Osada wrote the film adaptation. Its origins bring together different kinds of work: the conception of the avenger, her visual depiction, and the selection of episodes for a film starring Meiko Kaji.

Walkow’s feature includes his interview with Osada and explains a casting decision linked to the director. Kaji had worked with Fujita and was keen to collaborate with him again. Osada and Fujita also knew each other, although they had not yet made a film together. The collaboration allowed Kaji to move from contemporary roles to a period avenger. Osada, for his part, had been writing yakuza films. Fujita brought experience in youth films. The result brings together a story inherited from the manga and professionals who had worked in other kinds of crime stories.

View all articles in Kill Bill: a revenge story told in two volumes