Oswaldo Mobray and Pete Hicox: authority as a disguise

Oswaldo Mobray speaks about justice with the confidence of a professional. The revelation that he is really Pete Hicox turns that elegance into part of an act designed to conceal a crime.

An executioner who seems to give Ruth’s journey purpose

Oswaldo Mobray presents himself as the executioner of Red Rock. His presence seems to fit neatly with John Ruth’s mission: transporting Daisy to the place where she is due to be hanged. Tim Roth portrays this identity with refined manners, careful diction and a willingness to explain his trade. The character projects an air of order in a room full of men who distrust one another.

The identity is false. He is Pete Hicox, one of the gang members who have taken over the haberdashery to rescue Daisy. His role requires more than concealing his name: he must convince the others that he represents an institution beyond the conflict. If they accept him as an executioner, his words can carry a weight they would not have coming from an ordinary traveller.

The disguise is especially calculated because Ruth defines himself by bringing his prisoners to the gallows alive. The supposed executioner appears to be the next link in a professional chain. That common ground makes it possible to talk about procedures and punishment without the relationship seeming too suspicious. The criminal adopts the language his adversary uses to justify his work.

Roth’s performance sets formal delicacy against the violence of the trade he claims to practise. He can speak courteously about killing someone because he presents it as a regulated function. The gap between tone and content makes the speech compelling and sets up the later irony: the man explaining legitimate authority is using a lie to help carry out a criminal operation.

The difference between justice and revenge, spoken by an impostor

Mobray offers an explanation of why justice needs to be separated from personal satisfaction. His argument values procedure and the executioner’s distance from the condemned. The scene lets us hear a reasoned case in a world where almost everyone has financial interests, grievances or a desire for revenge. The speech seems to offer a standard by which to judge the violence that is approaching.

The revelation of his identity does not automatically make every point in that argument absurd. Someone who lies about who they are can still make a coherent distinction. The irony lies in the way his conduct contradicts the authority from which he speaks. The film asks us to separate the substance of an idea, the credibility of the person expressing it and the purpose they have in doing so.

The discussion of law and revenge takes on a different resonance in the conclusion. Warren and Mannix invoke the fate Ruth had planned for Daisy, but execute her in the midst of the conflict and without an external trial. The false executioner had described a distance that neither of them maintains. His performance thus introduces a standard that the film itself uses to make the resolution unsettling.

The character also shows how much weight a way of speaking can carry. Precision and refinement create an impression of competence, even though they do not prove the identity he claims. Mobray needs the others to mistake familiarity with professional discourse for proof that he really holds the position. His mask works because it offers an organised, seemingly reassuring explanation in a situation everyone wants to understand.

Pete Hicox, the gang and an off-screen family connection

The flashback to Domergue’s gang shows Pete taking part in preparing the deception. The haberdashery had been taken over before Ruth arrived, and the stories told by its guests had been coordinated. Once viewers know this background, they can revisit the executioner’s conversation and recognise it as one part of a collective performance.

The surname Hicox recalls Archie Hicox, the British lieutenant played by Michael Fassbender in Inglourious Basterds. The connection does not have to be inferred from the shared name alone: Tim Roth discussed it in an interview with CinemaBlend, describing Pete as Archie’s ancestor. In the same answer, he was unsure of the exact number of generations, so it is best not to claim a more precise genealogy than his comments allow.

That family connection comes from outside the story of The Hateful Eight. The film does not depict a family tree, and viewers do not need to know Archie to understand Pete. The connection between the two Hicoxes extends the interplay between the films, but does not by itself explain either man’s character, choices or fate.

The contribution of Tim Roth to Tarantino’s cinema takes a particularly theatrical form here: he plays a criminal playing a convincing official. His verbal elegance allows the lie to take centre stage before it is exposed. Pete Hicox shows just how readily a room can accept as an authority figure someone who has mastered its language, even when that mastery serves to destroy the order he claims to represent.

Return to the The Hateful Eight guide.

View all articles in The Hateful Eight: intrigue and distrust in the snow