Tarantino and the WGA: eligibility, credits and recognition

Quentin Tarantino’s relationship with the Writers Guild of America calls for three issues to be distinguished: award requirements, credit attribution and retrospective recognition of screenplays. Mixing them together produces an awards record that does not match the official records.

Why an absence is not the same as a defeat

Inglourious Basterds was not eligible for the Writers Guild of America awards for the 2009–2010 season. Information published at the time by TheWrap explained that the screenplay had not been made under the union agreements applicable to that competition. Its absence from the nominations therefore did not represent an unfavourable vote on its quality. The film was excluded before that comparison took place.

Coverage of that year’s awards identified Tarantino as a writer who was not a WGA member. It also clarified a crucial distinction: it was not essential for every candidate to be a union member personally; what mattered was whether the work was covered by the recognised agreements. Reducing the issue to “he did not want to join, so he lost” conflates a professional status with a competitive result that never took place.

Django Unchained was again left off the WGA Awards ballot in the season following its 2012 release. This was not an isolated exception reserved for Tarantino: other productions, including Amour and Beasts of the Southern Wild, also failed to meet that year’s eligibility requirements. The exclusions reflected the rules of the awards, not a list of films considered unworthy of artistic recognition.

The contrast with Tarantino’s Oscars for his screenplays helps make this clear. Django could win the Oscar for Original Screenplay without having taken part in the WGA writing competition. The institutions do not necessarily select from the same pool of works. For the same reason, the absence of a union nomination should not be treated as proof of a general rejection by American screenwriters.

The credits for True Romance and Natural Born Killers

True Romance, directed by Tony Scott, credits Quentin Tarantino as the screenwriter. In Natural Born Killers, directed by Oliver Stone, the credits recorded by the American Film Institute distinguish Tarantino’s story from the screenplay by David Veloz, Richard Rutowski and Stone. That distinction describes how the writing is credited in the completed films. By itself, it cannot reconstruct all the negotiations that took place before those credits were assigned.

A story and a screenplay are not interchangeable terms. The story may provide characters, situations and a narrative thread that later work develops or transforms. Recognising an original contribution does not mean attributing all the dialogue and decisions in the filmed version to the same author. In Natural Born Killers, keeping the names and roles separate avoids crediting Tarantino with writing the entirety of Stone’s finished film.

The WGA has procedures for determining credits and conducting arbitration. Its guide explains that literary materials and the contributions of participants are examined; the procedure has its own rules and is not an awards vote. But the existence of this system does not prove that a particular dispute was resolved through it. Specific evidence from the case file or documented testimony about its involvement is needed to claim that arbitration took place in a historical case.

The records compared here do not provide sufficient grounds to present True Romance and Natural Born Killers as two “Tarantino wins in WGA arbitrations”. Verifiable credits are a sounder starting point than that account. Nor is the author’s distance from an adaptation enough to infer a union sanction, a ruling or a ban on using his name.

Pulp Fiction on the list of great screenplays

Pulp Fiction could not compete in 1995 either: according to the Los Angeles Times, its production companies were not signatories to the union agreement.

The WGA does include Pulp Fiction on its list of the 101 greatest screenplays, where it ranks 16th. The entry names Quentin Tarantino’s screenplay and the story by Tarantino and Roger Avary. This is retrospective recognition of the writing, and it belongs to a selection spanning different eras of cinema. It should not be turned into an annual screenplay award won in 1994 or 1995.

Its presence on that list shows why the relationship between an institution and a work can have more than one dimension. A title may be recognised in a historical poll even though its participation in an annual competition is subject to different requirements. The useful details are the specific name of the list and the film’s position on it, not a cumulative count of supposed trophies.

Membership, eligibility, credit and recognition describe different facts. In Tarantino’s case, the records make it possible to explain exclusions in certain seasons, identify the credited writing on films directed by others, and note the later recognition of Pulp Fiction. Keeping these categories separate avoids attributing awards to him that he did not win or turning creative conflicts into unsubstantiated union procedures.

See Quentin Tarantino’s awards.

View all articles in Quentin Tarantino Awards: What He Won and in Which Categories