Who's That Knocking at My Door, Martin Scorsese's first feature film, offers a concrete point of comparison with Reservoir Dogs: the characters speak from within a culture of films and songs that shapes how they present themselves to others. Harvey Keitel appears in both titles, although J. R. and Mr. White occupy very different positions in their respective stories.
Tarantino's admiration for that debut is documented in his conversation with Scorsese for DGA Quarterly in 2019. There, he singled out the ferry scene in which Keitel's character talks about The Searchers. That recognition gives us a specific moment to start from, without reducing the relationship between the directors to the broad label of gangster cinema.
The songs offer another point of connection. Scorsese has explained their importance in imagining scenes through everyday experiences. In Tarantino's films, familiar recordings can set the rhythm for an introduction or accompany actions that radically change their effect. Examining these functions, alongside the work of editing, lets us appreciate both the affinities between the films and their differences.
A specific admiration: the ferry conversation
In «Wise Guys», the conversation published by DGA Quarterly in autumn 2019, Tarantino named the dialogue about Who's That Knocking at My Door as his favourite scene from the film: the conversation about The Searchers on the Staten Island Ferry. This is an expression of admiration for that moment; the conversation does not claim that the film was the specific source of the songs or cuts in Reservoir Dogs.
The AFI Catalog identifies Scorsese as director and screenwriter, Keitel as J. R., Zina Bethune as the young woman and Thelma Schoonmaker as editor. It also clarifies the difference between two commonly cited dates: the film was presented as I Call First at the Chicago Film Festival in November 1967, and opened in cinemas in that city under its familiar title in March 1969.
The ferry conversation is part of J. R.'s encounter with the young woman. Talking about films gives him a way to approach her and show his enthusiasm for something he considers important. The reference helps characterise the speaker: how much space he takes up, what he hopes to share and what aspects of his personality emerge as he explains a film.
This interest in Martin Scorsese's cinema helps us recognise an affinity with Tarantino's characters. In Reservoir Dogs, discussing a song also lets someone display confidence and offer an interpretation that others can accept or challenge. The group setting changes the role of the conversation: several voices compete to speak and steer the topic.
Keitel provides a visible link between the casts, but the behaviour of his characters points to a difference. J. R. presents himself to someone he has just met; White acts within a gang and must maintain his standing among his associates. Verbal ease has different consequences depending on whether it is used in a personal approach or in a relationship between criminals.
Songs as a starting point for a scene
In the public text of «The Power of Music», his MasterClass, Scorsese connects records, radio and music heard on the street with the way he imagines scenes. He mentions El Watusi, by Ray Barretto, as a decisive moment in shaping his first feature film. His explanation presents music as a creative impulse, associated with memories and situations.
That is why speaking only of the influence of rock leaves part of the question unanswered. What matters is what a recording does within the film: it can provide a duration, a pulse or a sense of familiarity that the image draws on. The sound brings its own energy, and the editing determines how to relate it to the behaviour on screen.
Reservoir Dogs clearly shows two different uses. The walk during the credits gains unity through Little Green Bag; the song helps present the men as a group. In the warehouse, Stuck in the Middle with You comes through the radio and accompanies Mr. Blonde. Here, listening is also part of the character's experience and behaviour.
Comparing this with Scorsese's explanation is useful because it shifts attention from the song chosen to its function. A recording can organise how we perceive movement or take part in the action. Its cinematic meaning depends on what happens while it plays, who is listening and how the framing draws the viewer into that experience.
Editing changes the relationship between music and behaviour
A film's rhythm is not explained only by how quickly the shots change. A cut can sustain an energy that has already been established or interrupt it to make us look differently. The duration of a conversation and the moment it is left behind matter as much as the number of images it contains.
In the same 2019 conversation, Scorsese recalled that learning to edit involved discovering that a shot could take on a different meaning when moved to another place. This observation makes the comparison more precise: editing affects the meaning of an image, as well as adjusting the pace at which we see it.
In Reservoir Dogs, the shift from the musical walk during the credits to the wounded Orange inside the car offers a precise example. The group's introduction gives way to physical urgency, dominated by the injured man's suffering and White's responses. The change immediately alters the viewer's relationship with these men and with the confidence their earlier appearance conveyed.
The ferry scene highlights another possibility: spending time on how a character speaks lets us get to know them through a cultural preference. The comparison thus brings together two different editing choices: lingering on an interaction and abruptly changing register. Both shape our relationship with the characters; appreciating how they work means paying attention to what each scene allows to unfold and when it chooses to move on.
The ferry scene offers a particularly useful way into this comparison because it turns a cinematic preference into behaviour. The focus is on the person speaking, the woman listening and the relationship he is trying to establish. Recognising the film being mentioned adds another layer of meaning, but the scene also lets us observe enthusiasm, initiative and a particular way of taking up space in a conversation.
Something similar happens with the songs. Knowing which recording is playing helps identify it; understanding its function means relating it to a specific action. The musical rhythm can unite an introduction, while hearing a song within the story reveals something about the person who chooses to accompany himself with that music. The editing determines how long that relationship lasts and what happens when it is interrupted.
Looking at both debuts through these choices lets us appreciate an affinity that extends to dialogue and sound without conflating their stories. The characters express themselves through cultural references, but the film transforms those references through context, duration and the presence of another person. This offers a more precise comparison than simply noting a shared actor or a collection of songs.
View all articles in Reservoir Dogs: the heist told through its aftermath
