Bestiality: the music from The Thing revisited in The Hateful Eight

Bestiality is part of the music Morricone wrote for The Thing. Its reuse connects two worlds of isolation and suspicion, but the Smithers scene calls for a distinction between the piano music and the score.

A composition predating the western

Music publisher Wise Music identifies Bestiality as music by Ennio Morricone from The Thing, John Carpenter’s 1982 film. Its use in The Hateful Eight does not make it a composition originally written for Tarantino. The credit should retain its provenance, even though some later recordings present it in connection with the western.

The distinction between a composition and a recording matters. A concert performance or a new release may reference The Hateful Eight because that film has given the piece a new lease of life. That does not mean it is the same take used in the film mix, or that its publication date is the date the music was created.

Decca’s commercial album does not contain all the music heard in the film either. Bestiality’s absence from its main track list does not invalidate its credited presence in the film. The album selects and organises material; it is not a complete inventory of every musical cue.

The Warren monologue should not be labelled automatically

Attributing Bestiality to Warren’s monologue addressed to Smithers is not sufficiently supported by the location documentation consulted. In that sequence, Bob’s performance of Silent Night on the piano is recognisable. Music guides place Bestiality in later moments of violence, including the aftermath of the poisoned coffee. It is best not to erase that distinction by associating the piece solely on the basis of its title.

The mistake is tempting because Warren’s story is cruel and the name Bestiality seems to describe it. However, semantic fit does not prove synchronisation. A title may suggest a scene to the reader without the corresponding music playing there. Identification should be based on the credits and the mix, not on a word matching disturbing content.

The piano inside the cabin also serves a different function from music the characters cannot hear. It shares the space with the conversation and can make the coexistence of a familiar melody and Warren’s story more uncomfortable. Confusing these two layers erases a key distinction in the scene’s sound design.

A connection between enclosed worlds that does not require identical monsters

The music’s origins in The Thing encourage a comparison between isolated groups who do not know whom to trust. The musical borrowing can evoke that memory for those who recognise its source. Those who do not know it can still experience its tension. The material’s effectiveness does not depend on passing a film-trivia test.

Nor does the similarity make the dangers identical. The western does not need an extraterrestrial organism to make its refuge feel unsafe. Its occupants can lie, act together in secret and exploit one another’s everyday needs. The reused music plays a part in this shift from a threat of a different kind to organised human violence.

Bestiality should therefore be understood as an earlier piece reused in a soundtrack that combines new music with existing material. Its origins are firmly identified; its precise placement calls for care. Keeping this distinction in mind makes it possible to explore its connection with horror without attributing a composition to Warren’s monologue simply because its title seems to describe it.

Return to the The Hateful Eight guide.

View all articles in The Hateful Eight: intrigue and distrust under the snow