Why Tarantino questions 1980s Hollywood cinema

His assessment of an era is a polemical intervention on Hollywood, not a ban on finding great films within it.

The 2022 statement and its scope

In November 2022, during a conversation on The Video Archives Podcast, Tarantino ranked the 1980s and the 1950s among Hollywood’s least highly regarded eras. He added the contemporary period to that comparison and acknowledged that the 1980s had been a time when he went to the cinema a lot. The statement was reported by NME and Rolling Stone, among other outlets.

The podcast’s context matters: Tarantino and Roger Avary discuss films from the perspective of viewers and former video-store workers. The episode devoted to Star 80, published on 8 November 2022, shows that a questioned decade can still receive close attention. The programme listing specifically highlights their discussion of Bob Fosse’s film and Eric Roberts’ performance.

The geographical scope also needs to be precise. A statement about Hollywood is not the same as a documented assessment of world cinema as a whole. Extending it without qualification to the film industries of Japan, France, Hong Kong or Latin America would change the proposition. Nor is there a single objective measure for ranking entire decades by quality. What we have is a critical judgement that can be debated through films, contexts and criteria.

An industrial era is not an individual film

In Cinema Speculation, Tarantino spells out one of his objections: the pressure to make protagonists who could be selfish and unlikeable more likeable or redeem them. Excerpts published by IndieWire and NME in November 2022 use Bill Murray’s comic persona to discuss this transformation. Tarantino does not think that taking the bite out of a character necessarily makes them more interesting.

The criticism is directed at a kind of moral closure. A story may allow uncomfortable behaviour for much of its duration, then resolve it through a conversion that gives the audience an acceptable figure again. The problem is not that a character changes, but that the change seems required by the story rather than a convincing consequence of what the character has experienced.

That criterion helps explain his affinity for characters who do not offer reassuring identification. Viewers can be drawn to someone and reject their actions, or recognise their intelligence without wanting to imitate them. When the script needs to eliminate that ambivalence to reach a conclusion, it loses one of the tensions that made the character distinctive. This is a specific explanation of his objection, not proof that every comedy of the decade repeats the same mechanism.

The comparison with the 1970s, which feature prominently in Cinema Speculation, also introduces a personal perspective. Films seen while a viewer is developing can become a lasting measure of intensity and freedom. Recognising that connection does not invalidate an assessment, but it helps explain why film history and the history of someone’s tastes are not quite the same story.

The problem arises when a preference becomes a rule that erases internal differences. The early and late years of a decade do not necessarily share the same conditions, and genres can respond in different ways to changing audiences. A family comedy, a thriller and an independent drama do not offer the same possibilities to the people who make them. A time-period label can help us find our bearings, but it should not replace those distinctions.

How to test the thesis without attributing other opinions to him

An editorial comparison can show the period’s diversity without pretending that Tarantino has endorsed every example. E.T., by Steven Spielberg, and Blade Runner, by Ridley Scott, were released in 1982 and offer very different relationships with the extraordinary. One builds much of its emotional force around care and separation; the other makes identity and recognition difficult problems to resolve.

The coexistence of these experiences makes it impossible to describe a year’s cinema solely through a uniform sense of optimism or darkness. It also invites us to distinguish between commercial success, initial reception and later prestige. A film can hold a central place in our memory of an era without having dominated the conversation in the same way when it was released. Retrospective history selects and rearranges.

Blue Velvet, David Lynch’s 1986 film, poses a different kind of question: what happens when a familiar domestic façade contains violence that is difficult to absorb. Its value in this comparison comes from the film itself, not from attributing a comment to Tarantino that has not been documented here. A rigorous discussion can include its own counterexamples without turning them into someone else’s recommendations.

The same applies to the 1950s. The existence of commercial conventions or historical restrictions does not erase the distinctive qualities of a particular directorial approach. To claim that a period is weak requires explaining how its general conditions relate to its specific results. If every exception is automatically dismissed, the thesis can no longer be tested and becomes a preference shielded from any response.

Tarantino’s intervention is more fruitful when it opens up that discussion than when it is used to shut it down. His knowledge of films and experience as a viewer make the opinion interesting, but do not turn it into a binding verdict. The debate about the 1980s invites us to ask what we expect from popular cinema: surprise, risk, emotion, ambiguity or continuity with a tradition. The answers can differ even among viewers who admire many of the same films.

See the guide to Tarantino’s books, criticism and film projects.

View all articles in Tarantino as a critic: books, podcasts and cinemas