Daisy sings a convict ballad that lets her take centre stage in the room for a few minutes. Choosing Jim Jones at Botany Bay turns a musical interlude into a declaration of resistance.
An Australian ballad in the haberdashery
The song Daisy Domergue performs on guitar is Jim Jones at Botany Bay, a traditional ballad associated with the transportation of British convicts to Australia. It was not composed by Ennio Morricone for the film. The Hateful Eight album includes Jennifer Jason Leigh’s performance and also credits Kurt Russell’s contribution. This identification helps avoid confusing the piece with Botany Bay, another song in the Australian tradition whose title is similar, but which is not the same song.
The story of Jim Jones pits a condemned man against punishment, exile and the authority that seeks to subdue him. It is told from the prisoner’s perspective, leaving room to imagine escape and revenge. Those elements are enough to understand why it fits the scene: Daisy is also in custody and refuses to accept that her fate will be decided by the man leading her to the gallows. The dramatic parallel does not make their two lives equivalent.
Traditional songs circulate in different versions, with variations in lyrics, melody and performance. It is more accurate here to identify Leigh’s film version than to automatically attribute to it every feature of an earlier recording. Nor can we conclude that Daisy is Australian because she knows the song. A song can travel further than its place of origin, and the film does not use this moment to establish the character’s nationality or explain where she learnt to play.
Within the musical selection, the ballad occupies a different place from the score by Morricone for The Hateful Eight. Its source is present on screen: we see Daisy making the music. The others can hear her, react and stop her. This makes the performance an action that changes the relationship between the characters, as well as giving the audience a song.
A prisoner’s voice finds an audience
Until this point, much of Daisy’s presence has been controlled by Ruth: he decides how to move her, when to silence her and how far she can move. The guitar gives her an activity she controls for a while. Her battered body remains in view, but attention shifts to her voice and hands. The scene lets us observe a skill the character has that does not depend on explanations of her crimes or her captor’s accusations.
The performance by Daisy Domergue in The Hateful Eight does not turn that interval into a sentimental confession. Leigh maintains a mixture of concentration, roughness and defiance. The song can begin as tolerated entertainment and end as a clear provocation. That shift matters because the threat does not come in a separate speech: it grows out of an activity that seemed acceptable during the wait imposed by the storm.
The lyrics Daisy sings are directed towards her situation and the man watching her. The possibility of escaping the hangman becomes too close for Ruth to treat as a distant story. The performance thus opens up two levels at once: a ballad anyone could listen to, and a message whose recipient is sitting beside the singer. There is no need to reproduce the lyrics to recognise the shift from traditional tale to immediate confrontation.
There is also a material imbalance that the music does not erase. Daisy can command attention, but she is still handcuffed and relies on Ruth tolerating the instrument. The scene does not present reclaimed freedom, but a small act of initiative within captivity. This difference explains why the end of the performance is so abrupt: the captor’s authority is still there to interrupt her as soon as he stops accepting the game.
The performance and its interruption
In an interview with NPR, Jennifer Jason Leigh explained that she learnt to play the guitar for the film and that the take used in the film captures a live performance. This detail helps us appreciate the physical work in the scene without inventing prior virtuosity or turning the actor into a professional traditional musician. The coordination between voice, instrument, posture and reaction to Russell is part of the performance. The scene feels authentic because Daisy seems to know what she is doing, and because the song retains the expressive irregularity of someone present in that room.
The blow with which John Ruth, the Hangman ends the performance is a response to that brief autonomy. Breaking the guitar takes away the means Daisy had used to direct attention and make her challenge. In the story, the instrument goes from being an opportunity for expression to demonstrating the captor’s ability to destroy it. The anecdote about the object used during filming is a separate matter; the action’s function is clear without confusing fiction with a production accident.
The sequence offers a clear example of diegetic and non-diegetic music in Tarantino. Here, the music belongs to the characters’ world, and its end has a visible physical cause. The silence that follows is not just the result of an editing decision: someone has stopped the song from continuing. The violence changes what we hear and makes the musical cut part of the conflict.
Daisy does not need to finish the ballad for her performance to have an effect. She has shown that she can take over a moment, unsettle Ruth and express an expectation different from the sentence he announces. The broken guitar ends the performance, but does not confirm that the prisoner has accepted defeat. The gap between interruption and submission sustains the tension as the film returns to the objects, looks and conversations in the haberdashery.
Return to the The Hateful Eight guide.
View all articles in The Hateful Eight: intrigue and distrust in the snow
