Tarantino has spoken about Scorsese as both a viewer and a colleague. Their conversation, published by the Directors Guild of America in 2019, offers a more precise understanding of their relationship than a collection of isolated compliments: they ask questions, disagree and examine how a film works.
Taxi Driver: Admiring an Uncomfortable Film
Taxi Driver was part of Tarantino’s selection for Sight and Sound in 2012. Years later, in the conversation with Scorsese published in DGA Quarterly in fall 2019, he explained his fascination with the violence of the ending and the position the film offers its viewer. The admiration is for a specific cinematic experience, not for the behaviour of its protagonist.
Travis Bickle observes New York through a mixture of isolation, resentment and a desire to find a mission. The film lets us get close to his perception without turning every idea he expresses into a reliable description of the world. That closeness is uncomfortable because it does not always offer an alternative voice to immediately put what we are seeing in order. The audience must reckon with the distance between a subjective experience and its consequences.
The diary and the night-time drives reinforce that intimacy. We share an accumulation of impressions that may seem routine before turning dangerous. The dramatic interest depends not only on when the violence will arrive, but on how someone reorganizes what they see until they feel authorized to act. The film does not need to present this process as an explanation that absolves the character.
The taxi cab offers a unique vantage point: Travis is close to many people and separate from them. He listens, drives them around and watches without necessarily becoming part of their lives. This physical closeness combined with isolation makes tangible a conflict that would be much more abstract if expressed only as loneliness. The city keeps moving even though he cannot find a way to take part.
In their 2019 exchange, Tarantino spoke about his cathartic response to the ending; Scorsese introduced his own relationship with threat and real-world violence. The conversation maintains a distinction between intention, personal experience and reception. The fact that a scene produces an emotional release does not, on its own, resolve all the moral questions it raises.
From cinephilia to working with shots and rhythm
The DGA dialogue also touched on the editing of The Irishman and decisions about its length and ending. Tarantino asked Scorsese about the pacing of an expansive narrative. This professional curiosity shows a form of respect that does not need to be summed up in an award or a grandiose statement: the interest lies in finding out how another director solves a particular problem.
Rhythm makes a good point of connection because it is not simply a matter of speeding up or slowing down a film. A pause can allow a situation to take on a different meaning. Returning to a conversation after a violent episode changes how we listen to the people speaking. In Scorsese’s films, observing a group’s habits helps us understand which rules it considers normal before those rules lead to catastrophe.
Tarantino also works with conversations, routines and delays, though their effects are not identical. The comparison is productive when it attends to the differences. A journey can bring the viewer closer to a character’s memories or make them wait for an explosion; a first-person voice can entice them, limit what they know or lay bare a contradiction.
Rather than treating Scorsese as a collection of ingredients Tarantino inherited, it is worth recognizing a dialogue between ways of seeing. Both give importance to their characters’ everyday culture, but they organize the relationship between memory, violence and spectacle differently. Their shared cinephilia does not erase the distinct choices each work makes.
An admiration that allows for debate
The book Cinema Speculation, published in 2022, places 1970s American cinema within Tarantino’s development as a viewer. His way of discussing films often starts with a personal reaction and moves towards an interpretation. Reading him as though he were offering a neutral record of production facts would mean missing this critical and subjective dimension.
The same applies to his opinions about an artist’s different periods. Preferring an early film does not automatically mean rejecting later ones. An objection to a scene does not erase admiration for an entire career, either. To discuss a specific criticism, it is necessary to identify the work in question and the context in which it was expressed; a supposed ongoing rivalry does not, on its own, explain his comments.
The 2019 conversation offers precisely a less rigid relationship. Tarantino can describe the effect Taxi Driver has on him, and Scorsese can respond from the perspective of the process that led to its filming. The result does not require them to agree on a single interpretation. It lets us see how a film remains open to interpretation even for those who know its construction from the inside.
That enduring quality is what gives Taxi Driver its power in this exchange. Its images invite technical admiration, unease and debate about audience identification. Tarantino approaches them with evident enthusiasm, but also with questions. This attitude explains his connection with Scorsese better than a definitive ranking of which of his mentors comes first.
Explore Tarantino’s selection of admired filmmakers and actors.
View all articles in The Filmmakers and Performers Quentin Tarantino Admires
