Reservoir Dogs and City on Fire: What They Share and What Changes

Reservoir Dogs and City on Fire share a recognizable dramatic situation: an undercover police officer develops a bond with a criminal, and that bond is exposed when the gang suspects a betrayal. Ringo Lam’s film, released in 1987, predates Quentin Tarantino’s 1992 debut. The relationship between the two films offers a way to examine how the same kind of conflict changes when its presentation is reorganized.

The similarity goes beyond the presence of guns or a botched robbery. It affects the tension between belonging to an institution and feeling indebted to someone in the group under investigation. An act of protection can contradict the role each character is supposed to play. This conflict unsettles the boundaries between ally, enemy and informant.

Discussion of the films’ influences has become entangled with a controversy over cinematic borrowing. To understand it, it helps to consider two levels: the relationships between the characters and how information is presented to the viewer. Identifying a specific predecessor does not yet tell us how much space it occupies in a film, how it is set up or what consequences it produces.

The undercover officer and loyalty under suspicion

The most precise connection lies in the conflict between a police mission and a personal relationship. The undercover officer needs to seem credible to the criminals, but the trust he earns does not remain a consequence-free tool. When someone in the group treats him like a friend, the investigation comes at a cost that the character cannot resolve simply by remembering which side he is on.

The City on Fire listing on Criterion Channel identifies Chow Yun-fat as Ko Chow, a police officer who infiltrates a gang and forms a bond with its leader, played by Danny Lee. After a robbery leads to a shootout, the thieves suspect there is an informant among them. This combination of infiltration, closeness and distrust provides a concrete basis for comparing the films.

In Reservoir Dogs, the relationship between Mr. Orange and Mr. White lets us consider the problem through the behaviour of the person who trusts. White helps a man he considers a friend. His judgement is based on how he is treated and on a shared situation; because viewers know Orange’s identity, they have information that changes the meaning of that help. The protection can be sincere and based on a mistaken belief.

The similarity is interesting because of this contradiction. Loyalty does not guarantee that you know another person, and discovering someone’s identity does not make everything you experienced with them false. Comparing only who carries a gun misses this mechanism. Both stories pit categories that seemed clear against each other: police officer and criminal describe positions, while friend and traitor depend on a relationship put to the test by events.

A similar climax within different structures

In his analysis for the BFI, updated in January 2022, Leigh Singer points to the undercover officer and the final armed confrontation as connections to Lam’s film. He also highlights a verifiable difference: City on Fire shows the robbery, while Reservoir Dogs omits it. Tarantino’s viewers are given the consequences and different accounts of a central action they have not seen.

The omission changes the role of the conversations. When the survivors explain what went wrong, there is no complete image of the robbery against which to check each statement. The focus shifts to who is speaking, what they might have seen and what interest they have in defending an explanation. An accusation can seem convincing because of the confidence with which it is delivered, even though there is not yet enough information to verify it.

The undercover officer’s journey also changes. City on Fire places viewers alongside Ko Chow and his police assignment; Reservoir Dogs withholds Orange’s identity until after we have seen White protect him. The revelation forces us to reconsider a relationship that began before our eyes. The effect depends on first seeing how the two men rely on each other, and then learning that their true positions are different.

The armed confrontation brings these relationships together in an immediate decision: believe an accusation, maintain trust or accept another man’s interpretation. The characters can share the same space while holding incompatible information. This explains why the visual connection is so recognizable, but also why its significance changes depending on what each film has revealed up to that point.

The reordering of events has other precedents. The connection to The Killing, by Stanley Kubrick places Tarantino’s story within a tradition of heist films told out of chronological order. Identifying that tradition helps clarify the comparison with Lam: a similarity in the conflict does not, by itself, explain all the narrative choices in Reservoir Dogs.

Mike White’s mashup and Tarantino’s response

Mike White turned the comparison into a critical intervention with Who Do You Think You're Fooling?. In “Jealous Much?”, published on his Impossible Funky Productions blog on June 26, 2015, White identifies the work as a 1994 piece he helped create to compare City on Fire with Reservoir Dogs. That is the correct title; it should not be confused with other documentaries about Tarantino.

His method brings together material from both films to make the borrowing he challenges perceptible. It is important to attribute that argument to White: the mashup constructs a critical reading through the selection and juxtaposition of clips. From there, the debate can address the significance of the parallels, how much the new narrative relationships transform them, and what recognition the earlier work receives.

Tarantino responded directly to questions about the influence at a 25th-anniversary event held at Sundance in 2017. Chris Bumbray quoted him in JoBlo: he acknowledged that City on Fire had inspired him, rejected describing his film as a remake that merely paraphrased it, and explained that he had developed a feature film from the situation in its final 10 minutes.

That recollection expresses how the director defends the transformation of the material; it does not replace an examination of the films. White’s objection emphasizes the recognizable correspondences, while Tarantino focuses on the expansion of a situation. These are two different ways of assessing borrowing. The discussion of cinematic pastiche starts here with identifiable choices: which conflict is retained, what information is delayed, and which relationship comes to shape the viewer’s experience.

When comparing clips, the boundaries of each excerpt influence what seems to match. Two similar shots can draw attention to a stance or the way guns are positioned; a longer sequence makes it possible to see how that stance is reached and how long it lasts. To assess the connection, it helps to keep in mind the question that drives each scene: what is a character trying to find out, what does the viewer already believe, and what action could change the situation?

The soundtrack deserves the same attention. Changing the dialogue accompanying an image can suggest an equivalence that the original edit did not make in that way. The technique can be useful as a comparative argument, provided we distinguish the construction of the essay from the construction of the film. A similar gesture, the function of a scene and the overall structure of a story are different scales of analysis. Keeping them separate makes it possible to discuss concrete examples without requiring any one similarity to explain the entire feature film.

View all articles in Reservoir Dogs: the heist told through its aftermath