Nation’s Pride: the fictional propaganda film and Eli Roth’s short film

Nation’s Pride exists on two levels: as a propaganda feature film within the story and as footage shot for Inglourious Basterds. Its real-life creators and those who appear in the fiction are not interchangeable.

The film the regime wants to celebrate

Nation’s Pride, also called Stolz der Nation or Nation’s Pride, turns the exploits attributed to Fredrick Zoller into a propaganda film. The soldier plays a version of himself, while Goebbels’ apparatus uses his image to present a heroic view of the war. Within the story, the production has a gala premiere and the political significance of an official event. It is not a historical documentary recovered by Tarantino, but a film invented for his fiction.

The gap between Zoller and the image projected of him matters more than an exact reconstruction of a battle. On screen, his shots are arranged as a demonstration of efficiency and superiority. The editing reduces his opponents to targets that fall, while giving the protagonist visual dominance. This mode of representation helps explain what propaganda seeks to do: establish an interpretation of violence before the audience can consider the experience of those who suffer it.

The premiere also lets us observe the audience for this propaganda. Their reactions are part of the meaning of the film within the film. The auditorium does not receive the images as a warning against war, but as an occasion for celebration. Tarantino’s film makes the outside audience watch the inside audience enjoy violence directed against others. This double perspective complicates the satisfaction that may later come from the reversal of the situation.

The character of Fredrick Zoller is not defined entirely by his heroic portrayal. His behaviour off screen and his relationship with what is projected introduce a distance that merits its own analysis. To understand Nation’s Pride, it is enough to recognise that a person and a public image are not the same thing. Propaganda selects, repeats and arranges actions to turn them into a narrative useful to the power funding the screening.

What Eli Roth filmed and how it was incorporated

In the real production, Eli Roth directed the footage for the film within the film, with Daniel Brühl as Zoller. The short film also features Bo Svenson as an American colonel. The clips shown within the feature film are not the same as the entire piece that was shot. Editions that include the short as a bonus feature allow viewers to see it with a different continuity, separate from the auditorium’s reactions and the events that interrupt the screening in the main story.

This distinction avoids confusion about the running time. Within the fiction, the film is described as one intended to fill a screening and made up of several reels. The real footage prepared to represent it is much shorter. The running time of the fictional feature should not be calculated from the bonus feature, nor should we assume that Tarantino needed to produce a complete propaganda film as long as the characters claim it is. Cinema can suggest a larger work through a section created for that purpose.

In interviews, Roth explained that he worked on editing the footage while the principal photography was still under way. Even so, the incorporation of these shots into Inglourious Basterds belongs to the editing of the feature film, credited to Sally Menke. These are related but distinct tasks. One is to build continuity for a battle short; another is to decide when the outside audience sees it, how long it stays on screen, and when to cut to a face, a booth or an action outside the auditorium.

The collaboration can be understood as part of Eli Roth’s work with Tarantino, without attributing every department of the film within the film to him. Directing a short film does not automatically make its director the composer, sole editor or person responsible for every sound effect. Credits should be read by role and by version. The film that appears within the fiction also adds invented names, which should not be confused with the real professionals who worked on the production.

Music and the texture of an apparently old print

The musical opening of the film within the film uses pre-existing material associated with Angelo Francesco Lavagnino, from The Last Days of Pompeii. This reference does not mean that Lavagnino composed a new score for Roth’s short, or that his music was written for a Nazi production. It is a reuse within a 2009 film that creates a historical appearance using elements from different sources. Identifying one specific piece also does not, by itself, identify every musical excerpt in the edit.

The sound treatment, however, has been directly explained by the team. Wylie Stateman and Harry Cohen worked on a mix that would evoke the limitations of a film from the late 1930s or early 1940s. They explored playback through an old loudspeaker and a digital processing chain; the digital option was chosen. This process shows that a sound which seems old can be the result of deliberate contemporary construction.

The sound texture helps distinguish the two levels of image. When we hear the film within the film, the gunshots and voices seem to belong to a print being screened in a theatre. When the action returns to the audience, the space of the premiere reappears. This difference allows us to move between representation and event without relying only on black and white. The ear helps identify the place from which each sound comes and the distance separating it from the viewer.

The purpose of this work becomes clear in the screening of Nation’s Pride: the film within the film must register as a spectacle before it is interrupted by another message. Its conventions establish an expectation of authority and control. The later intrusion changes precisely that relationship between image, audience and owner of the venue. The rupture works because the propaganda has first acquired a sufficiently concrete audiovisual form.

Return to the Inglourious Basterds guide.

View all articles in Inglourious Basterds: language, cinema and revenge in occupied France