Why Tarantino champions Stallone in Paradise Alley

Before the major franchises, Stallone wrote and directed films about neighbourhoods, brothers and people chasing success—work that deserves a closer look in its own right.

Stallone before he was reduced to his icons

Quentin Tarantino’s case for Sylvester Stallone gives particular importance to Paradise Alley, his 1978 directorial debut. In Cinema Speculation, published in 2022, he devotes a chapter to it. A review of the book published in Momentary Cinema on 22 October 2023 notes that Tarantino appreciates Stallone’s character as a writer and the film’s distinctive vision, while acknowledging its unevenness. The focus is on one particular work, not on declaring the actor’s entire career flawless.

To understand that choice, it’s worth setting aside, for a moment, the most familiar image of Stallone. His physique and later characters came to dominate much of the public conversation, but writing a scene set in a neighbourhood and directing an action film don’t call for exactly the same decisions. Paradise Alleyoffers a chance to observe a creator who shapes relationships, invents voices and builds an atmosphere around three brothers. Physical strength is part of that world; it doesn’t explain the whole of it.

It’s also important to distinguish between the credits on each film. Stallone wrote and starred in Rocky, released in 1976 and directed by John G. Avildsen. In Rocky II, released in 1979, he also took on the directing. Paradise Alley sits between the two. This sequence shows that his career as a filmmaker didn’t simply begin by extending an established commercial brand: first, he tried his hand at another story, with different characters and a different balance of humour, spectacle and melodrama.

Paradise Alley: words, brothers and a wrestling ring

The film places the Carboni brothers in 1940s New York. Cosmo, played by Stallone, brings a verbal energy that contrasts with Victor’s physical power. Lenny completes a triangle of interests and affections that don’t always pull in the same direction. Wrestling offers a chance to make money, but that opportunity also changes the way each brother sees the others. A way to get ahead can become a way to exploit one another.

The neighbourhood has its own dramatic purpose. The encounters, conversations and small businesses give a human scale to a story that could have been limited to setting up fights. The film pays attention to the people around its protagonists, although not all those storylines are developed to the same degree. That abundance gives the film a sense of life and, at the same time, creates some of its imbalances. Part of its character comes from allowing the setting to spill beyond the main plot.

Cosmo is especially useful for observing Stallone the writer. His authority doesn’t come solely from physical dominance. He tries to persuade, sell a possibility and draw others into the story he is proposing. Words are a tool for survival. The character can be amusing and irritating in the same exchange, because his imagination goes hand in hand with self-interest and an obvious difficulty in gauging the consequences of his ideas.

The wrestling ring turns these family tensions into a public spectacle. The body taking the punishment belongs to one person, while others calculate what that punishment might yield. The film thus sets the excitement of the bout against a less comfortable question: who makes the decisions, and who pays the price? There’s no need to cast the brothers as fixed symbols to see the inequality that takes hold between them when the prospect of making money seems to justify everything.

Rocky II and the responsibility of directing a sequel

In Five Things, featured in W in April 2020, Tarantino named Rocky II as his personal favourite film of 1979 and praised Stallone’s performance. The comment also supports his interest in the sequel.

Rocky IIposes a different problem. The audience knows Rocky and expects to find a familiar emotional experience again. The sequel must preserve that familiarity while explaining why the character needs to keep fighting. Stallone now has a character whose way of speaking, awkwardness and stubbornness already mean something to the audience. Directing him means deciding how much he can change without losing what made him relatable.

Life outside the ring is essential to that task. Work, money, his relationship with Adrian and the difficulties of adjusting to a new life prevent the return to the ring from being a mere genre obligation. Rocky has to find his place in a world that doesn’t organise itself around physical endurance. His dignity depends on more than taking punches. He remains vulnerable when there’s no visible opponent to face.

Comparing the two films reveals two ways of working with popular melodrama. Paradise Alleyshares the attention between brothers and a more loosely connected setting; Rocky IIconcentrates much of its energy on a central character who carries the memory of the previous film. In both, physical effort needs an emotional story to matter. A fight can be exciting in itself, but it only has consequences when we know what relationship, desire or promise is at stake.

Tarantino’s championing of Stallone invites us to take another look at his work as a writer and director. It doesn’t require us to consider an oddity superior to a hit, or to excuse all its problems. It asks us to give Stallone the same attention we give other popular auteurs: to look at how he builds characters, what tone he aims for and what world he brings to life from one scene to the next. Paradise Alleyis a particularly revealing place to start, because it preserves ambitions that the later image of its star may have pushed into the background.

Explore the selection of filmmakers and actors admired by Tarantino.

View all articles in The filmmakers and performers Quentin Tarantino admires