My Best Friend’s Birthday: a learning film with Craig Hamann

The project that preceded Reservoir Dogs is often remembered through a story about destroyed footage. Accounts from those involved offer a more complex explanation of how it was made and abandoned.

A shared project before the professional debut

My Best Friend’s Birthday was a feature-film attempt developed by Quentin Tarantino and Craig Hamann during the 1980s. Its unfinished state matters as much as its place in the chronology. It should not be presented as a commercial release on a par with Reservoir Dogs, or added without explanation to the numbering the director uses for his filmography. It is an early project that offers a glimpse of a period of learning and collaboration before public recognition.

In an interview published by Trainwreck’d Society in February 2020, Hamann traced the start of his friendship with Tarantino to classes with James Best. He rejected the idea that he had started the film on his own and that Tarantino later joined a project that already belonged to someone else: he recalled a shared decision to make a film. He also identified the camera as a Bolex 16 mm camera lent by Fred Olen Ray. These are details attributed to a participant, not inferred from a circulating copy.

Hamann’s precise account corrects a common tendency in the biographies of celebrated filmmakers. When one collaborator becomes much more famous, the others can be turned in retrospect into mere assistants. Here, the story requires us to preserve the shared authorship of the screenplay and recognize genuine creative contributions. Acknowledging Tarantino as director does not require erasing who worked with him or recasting the entire project as a solitary creation.

The film was conceived as a black-and-white comedy. That starting point matters too: the future creator of Reservoir Dogs was not interested only in preparing stories about armed criminals. Comedy makes it possible to work with misunderstandings, shifts in expectations and differences in people’s attitudes. Its existence broadens our picture of his early interests, even if an unfinished work cannot reveal a complete artistic programme.

Shooting in stages did not guarantee the film would come together in the edit

Andrew J. Rausch brought together interviews for the book My Best Friend’s Birthday: The Making of a Quentin Tarantino Film, published in 2019. In a June 2023 interview with Bulletproof Screenwriting, he described a production sustained by limited resources and work accumulated over a long period. He also distinguished between an initial draft by Hamann and its later expansion with Tarantino. That account of the film’s development can coexist with Hamann’s recollection of a shared initiative.

Writing the first draft does not necessarily mean originating the entire project alone. It helps to distinguish the decision to make the film, the first draft and the later revisions. These are different stages of a collaboration. Oral history can offer complementary accounts of them without requiring the writer to turn every difference in emphasis into a personal dispute.

The use of a borrowed camera offers a glimpse of another gap between ambition and production. Access to the equipment makes shooting possible, but it does not solve the challenges of coordinating performers, maintaining continuity or organizing the footage. Each day of shooting must produce fragments that can be connected later. A conversation that seems to work during filming can reveal problems when placed alongside the other scenes.

That is why editing plays a decisive role in this story. It is not merely where an already successful film is put in order: it can also show that the material does not sustain the imagined experience. Disappointment with the result does not erase the learning, even if it prevents the project from becoming a finished work ready for release. Completing the shoot for some sequences and achieving a coherent feature film are different goals.

The fire story needs attribution and nuance

The most frequently repeated version holds that a laboratory fire destroyed much of the footage. Rausch challenged that explanation in the 2023 interview. According to his research, some material was damaged, but not enough to determine the project’s fate on its own. He attributed the abandonment mainly to Tarantino’s dissatisfaction while editing what had been shot. This should be presented as the conclusion documented by that researcher, rather than turning earlier rumours into an unquestionable fact.

That correction changes how we read the film. An external accident creates a story of a work snatched away from its creators; abandoning it after assessing the results describes a problem of learning and judgement. Both situations can leave material incomplete, but they do not mean the same thing. The existence of fragments alone cannot tell us why others are missing, or how much was filmed or preserved on each format.

The incomplete edit that has circulated, running a little over half an hour, should not be mistaken for everything that was shot either. A copy available to viewers may be a selection, while other elements remain out of circulation. Without a complete inventory of the physical materials, it is too much to claim that exactly and only what appears in a particular video survives. The length of the copy consulted and the extent of the preserved archive are separate questions.

Its historical value does not depend on treating it as a secret masterpiece. It lets us observe people trying to move from admiring cinema to organizing a film of their own. The project brings together friendship, writing, borrowed resources and editing challenges. Tarantino’s later career makes the experience interesting, but it does not retroactively change the project’s unfinished state or diminish Hamann’s contribution. My Best Friend’s Birthday matters as a shared work and an attempt to learn by doing, with results its creators could not yet fully control.

Continue to Tarantino’s origins and early development.

View all articles in Tarantino’s beginnings: acting, the video store and early films