Wuxia and kung fu in Pai Mei’s training

The tribute to wuxia in Kill Bill intersects with a more specific tradition during the Pai Mei episode: kung fu cinema centred on learning. The distinction helps identify what Tarantino draws from his influences. The retired master, the admission test and a fighter’s transformation through exercises form a story with its own rules within Beatrix’s tale of revenge.

Shaw Brothers is a production company associated with many martial arts films, with varied plots, directors and tones. Its name helps situate a catalogue; identifying the episode’s references also requires looking at the characters, actors and the way effort is presented.

Gordon Liu’s presence, Lo Lieh’s earlier portrayal of Pai Mei and the texture of the cinematography establish different connections. Some are rooted in casting and characterization; others affect how a display of skill is seen. Together, they make Beatrix’s recollection a recognizable episode of martial arts training cinema.

Wuxia, kung fu and the space of learning

In his introduction to the BFI’s A Century of Chinese Cinema series, Noah Cowan distinguishes wuxia, associated with swordsman adventures and the chivalric tradition, from the development of kung fu cinema centred on unarmed combat. These are trends that help identify narrative and visual priorities, with areas of overlap between them.

The Pai Mei episode lets us apply this distinction by considering what the action is meant to do. The focus is on acquiring an ability, accepting correction and facing a new test. The master’s superiority is first presented as something Beatrix can experience, but not yet replicate. This distance shapes the scene more powerfully than a conflict between opposing sides or a mission to be completed outside the compound.

When Pai Mei balances on Beatrix’s sword, the demonstration goes beyond realistic standards. The episode can focus on training while retaining a fantastical physical ability. Learning provides the structure for showing it.

The secluded space brings the relationships into focus. Beatrix enters a place whose rules she does not know, where her past experience must be put to the test. The courtyard provides a setting for demonstrations; moments of living together extend the teaching. The setting allows the story to move from displays of skill to their effects on the student without continually introducing new adversaries. Everyday life and combat are brought close together.

Within Tarantino’s tribute to Asian martial arts cinema, this episode adopts a rhythm of interruptions, attempts and observation. The pauses give importance to what the character still cannot do. Progress needs screen time and a situation in which results can be compared, even when the editing condenses the training period.

Lo Lieh, Gordon Liu and two different precedents

The UCLA Film & Television Archive’s entry for Executioners from Shaolin identifies Lau Kar-leung as the director of the 1977 film and Lo Lieh as Pai Mei. There, the white-browed master takes the place of the enemy. This precedent makes it possible to recognize that Tarantino is bringing back an earlier cinematic figure, whose appearance and menacing authority were already associated with kung fu cinema.

Released in 1980, Clan of the White Lotus offers another combination. Lo Lieh directed the film and plays White Lotus, the main antagonist; Gordon Liu plays Hung Wei Ting. The Celestial Pictures catalogue and Will Kouf’s review published by Shaw Brothers Universe help distinguish these roles. White Lotus and Pai Mei should not be turned into a single character simply because they share an actor and a similar characterization.

In Kill Bill: Vol. 2, Gordon Liu takes on the role of the master who sets the test. For viewers familiar with those films, his presence changes the perspective from which the training is seen: an actor associated with the hero who has to improve now plays someone who seems to have all the answers. This relationship between roles can be appreciated on screen without attributing the personality of any of them to the actor.

The use of the old man’s authority also changes. In her encounter with Pai Mei, Beatrix has to stay close to someone whose superiority she has just experienced. The master takes on a role that requires them to live together: he can reject her, demand more of her or pass on his knowledge. That continuity turns the imbalance of their first confrontation into the starting point for a relationship. The recollection includes an extended negotiation over who can learn and under what conditions.

The look of old-school kung fu cinema

Robert Richardson explained to John Pavlus in American Cinematographer that the training scenes used photochemical duplication to reproduce the contrast and deterioration of old kung fu film prints.

The master’s demonstration makes use of a visible difference in effort. As Beatrix tries to respond, he seems to have time to judge her. The exchange can be read as comic because of this imbalance, even though the student experiences its consequences as failure. The scene can be threatening and mocking at the same time. The viewer watches the display from a different position than Beatrix does: they can appreciate Pai Mei’s theatrical excess while she has to endure it.

The master’s presentation is part of this stylization. His eyebrows and beard make his face recognizable before the action proves his ability. His gestures extend the impression of mastery: he can pause, watch Beatrix and wait for her response. The alternation between his confidence and her difficulty makes the difference between them clear without relying on lengthy explanations of their respective knowledge.

The training of Beatrix with Pai Mei therefore brings together techniques working at different scales: the character’s appearance, the presentation of the space and the time given to learning. Similarities to its influences allow for changes in function. Beatrix remains the protagonist of a revenge story, but during this episode her immediate task is to learn. The film gives her the role of student after showing what she can do as an adversary.

These precedents also make it possible to see who passes on knowledge. In UCLA’s notes on Executioners from Shaolin, Cheng-Sim Lim points out that the son combines his father’s teachings, associated with the tiger, with his mother’s, associated with the crane. His training depends on bringing together different family contributions.

Will Kouf highlights a comparable intervention in Clan of the White Lotus: Mei Ha, played by Kara Hui, helps the hero change how he approaches the problem. The presence of women in these stories thus includes the passing on of knowledge that is crucial to the protagonist.

This variety adds nuance to the image of a genre made up exclusively of male masters passing knowledge on to male students. Beatrix’s entry into the role of student is part of a tradition that already offered women different positions. Comparing who teaches, who listens and who ultimately uses what they have learned lets us appreciate the changes Kill Bill makes without reducing its influences to a single formula.

View all articles in Kill Bill: A Revenge Told in Two Volumes