John Milius through Tarantino’s eyes: scripts, heroes and Big Wednesday

Milius holds a distinctive place in Tarantino’s cinephilia: his characters can speak like legends before they learn to live like people.

A preference that allows for differences

Quentin Tarantino has championed John Milius without reducing his filmography to a collection of men with guns. In a New Beverly review republished by Rotten Tomatoes on 22 June 2020, he named Dillinger as his personal favourite, while acknowledging Big Wednesday as the film that could be considered its director’s classic. The distinction is revealing: a favourite work and a representative work need not be one and the same. Nor does this amount to a definitive ranking of all his scripts.

Dillinger, released in 1973, and Big Wednesday, from 1978, seem to belong to separate worlds. One builds its story around criminals on the run; the other follows surfers as they move from youth into adulthood. Yet both invite us to consider the relationship between a group and the image it wants to leave of itself. Adventure becomes a way of making a legend, and the legend can outlast the people who sustain it.

That connection helps explain the interest of a viewer like Tarantino. Milius’s characters rarely settle for serving a practical purpose. They talk, compete and show off as if someone will tell their story later. The gestures have a ceremonial quality. A confrontation, a farewell or a man entering a room can matter as much for its effect on others as for what it changes in the action.

Big Wednesday and the epic of losing your youth

Big Wednesdayfollows Matt, Jack and Leroy, played by Jan-Michael Vincent, William Katt and Gary Busey. Their friendship unfolds around surfing, but the ocean is not all the film is about. It is also about ageing bodies, new responsibilities and the separations that make it impossible to preserve a way of life intact. The beach offers a place to return to; it cannot take the protagonists back to exactly where they started.

The structure lets us feel time passing in the differences between reunions. The jokes and physical energy take on a different meaning when they return after an absence. We come to know the friends as a group, then learn to see them as individuals with different destinies. That tension stops nostalgia from becoming just a series of pleasant snapshots. Remembering something also means recognising that it can never happen again in quite the same way.

The surfing sequences lend the film a scale that transforms intimate conflicts into spectacular images. Against the waves, a person seems small without ceasing to be the focus of our attention. The challenge is to keep your balance in the face of a force you cannot completely control. As a reading of the film, that relationship captures the distance between the confidence of youth and the later experience of its limits. There is no need to turn every wave into an allegory to see it.

The reunion therefore carries a different kind of emotion from a conventional sporting victory. The question is not simply who performs a manoeuvre best. What matters is that the characters once again share a place whose meaning has changed. The celebration contains a farewell, and the farewell makes it possible to recognise the value of what they have experienced. It is an epic of mates that endures precisely because it cannot make youth last for ever.

The screenwriter behind the monumental voice

To appreciate Milius, it helps to distinguish his work as a director from his contributions to other people’s films. His writing credits include Apocalypse Now and Big Wednesday, the latter co-written with Dennis Aaberg. Acknowledging those collaborations avoids crediting him alone for every decision in a collective work. It also lets us consider what a screenwriter can contribute before performances, editing and direction alter the effect of their words.

In his stories, dialogue often establishes a relationship with codes of conduct. Characters talk about courage, loyalty or belonging, but then have to act in circumstances that make it difficult to uphold those ideas. The dramatic force comes from the gap between what they say and how they behave. A grand declaration can be sincere, ridiculous or both; what matters is how the scene puts the speaker to the test.

That is why it is not enough to describe his writing as a collection of emphatic lines. A line needs a situation to give it weight. The anticipation of a confrontation, a mate’s gaze or the awareness of defeat can turn a few words into a promise that is hard to keep. Milius’s larger-than-life style works best when it preserves that fragility beneath the surface.

Tarantino’s assessment invites us to revisit that breadth: the director of Dillinger is also capable of building a story around friendship and loss. For context on other debates about writers, versions and films of the seventies, Cinema Speculation offers insight into his work as a critic. A survey of Milius is richer when it compares specific films, without turning admiration into automatic approval of every character, speech or career decision.

Explore our selection of filmmakers and actors admired by Tarantino.

View all articles in The filmmakers and performers Quentin Tarantino admires