Tarantino’s defence of celluloid brings together an aesthetic experience and material choices. To understand it, we need to distinguish how a film is shot, how it is screened and how it is preserved.
The Cannes statement and what it was really about
At the Cannes press conference on 23 May 2014, Quentin Tarantino voiced his opposition to the replacement of photochemical projection with digital projection. He described this change as the disappearance of cinema as he had known it, and compared digital exhibition to television. This was a personal assessment of the cinematic experience, not a universally accepted technical definition.
Precision about projection matters. Shooting on film does not guarantee that audiences will see a photochemical print: images can be digitised and screened from a file. Conversely, the medium of a screening print does not necessarily reveal every process used to produce it. The camera, post-production and projector belong to related but different stages.
His argument is best understood as a defence of an entire practice. The capture medium preserves a texture and certain working choices; the projected print brings its own materiality; the theatre shapes the audience’s attention. For Tarantino, losing any one of these parts affects the meaning of the whole. It is possible to understand this position without claiming that a digital work is no longer cinema or lacks artistic value.
It is also worth distinguishing the director’s preference from a comparison of the quality of two specific functions. What audiences see depends on the condition of the materials, how the print has been prepared, the equipment and the conditions in the theatre. Format is an important choice, but it cannot replace the work of exhibition. A prestigious name for a medium cannot, by itself, fix a poorly presented image.
The Hateful Eight: turning a preference into a release
The Hateful Eight offers one of the clearest examples of this commitment to materiality. The film was shot on 65 mm using the Ultra Panavision 70 system and had a special release on 70 mm prints. The difference in numbers is not a contradiction: they describe capture and exhibition formats. The project required the revival of projection conditions that many theatres no longer used regularly.
Kodak devoted two conversations to its production and exhibition, published in December 2015 and January 2016. They covered both photochemical work and the challenges of screening 70 mm again in different theatres. The case shows that the decision did not end with choosing the camera: it required a chain capable of bringing the image to audiences in the intended format.
The breadth of the image is especially interesting in a film dominated by an interior and a group of characters. A wide format can organise relationships, distances and glances happening at once, as well as show landscapes. There is no aesthetic rule that reserves large-format film for mountains or armies. The analysis of Ultra Panavision 70 in The Hateful Eight explores this specific application.
The versions of The Hateful Eight call for another distinction: the medium and the edit are not the same thing. A presentation may change the duration, structure or elements of the screening, while another difference may concern the print used. Confusing these two dimensions makes it harder to know what each viewer has seen and attributes changes to the format that belong to the edit.
The New Beverly Cinema takes the defence of the medium into the work of an exhibitor. Keeping a programme of prints means that this preference is not reduced to statements at festivals. The decision affects which materials are available and how each screening is presented. Audiences can therefore compare real experiences, rather than simply imagine the difference based on a controversy.
Preservation is not about picking a side
Preservation brings its own challenges. Physical film requires suitable storage and care; a digital file requires management, verification and technological continuity. The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has studied these differences and notes that preserving digital materials requires active infrastructure, including updates and transfers to new storage media. The existence of a file does not, by itself, guarantee its survival indefinitely.
Nor does a projection print automatically replace the negative or preservation materials. It may have historical value, preserve a version or enable a screening, but its use and condition must be taken into account. Collecting, restoring and preserving are related activities, but they are not interchangeable. Defending an analogue experience does not diminish the usefulness of other tools for studying and recovering images.
Celluloid also appears as a narrative subject within his own films. The cinema of Le Gamaar in Inglourious Basterds makes exhibition part of the action; the damaged-film effects in Grindhouse evoke a memory of circulation and wear. These are expressive uses, not technical proof that all deterioration improves a work.
Tarantino’s position can therefore be read as a defence of possibilities he does not want to lose. His words are deliberately emphatic; his productions and cinemas allow us to see what he does with that conviction. The discussion becomes more precise when it distinguishes taste, professional practice and preservation, rather than making every photochemical or digital film a compulsory representative of a single aesthetic.
Back to Tarantino books, criticism and film projects.
View all articles in Tarantino as a critic: books, podcasts and cinemas
